Originally posted by mghrn55
You missed my point.
My question was ....
Why switch to ELO rating system when we already have a formula ?
I fully support decouple of clan rating from tournament rating.
I still think my original proposal sorts out most problems
It appears there are 4 things that are to be considered
1 Collusion
2 Sandbagging
3 Dead players
4 Points awarded for a win
1 The way around collusion would be that a clan cannot challenge the same clan in a 90 day period
2 The way to stop sandbagging would be the player who resigns there would be no rating change
I would like to see that one back dated to the 1st of January
3 The way to stop dead players would be to able participate in a challenge player must have moved in the last 14 days
4 Points should be awarded on the size of the challenge
So that a 10 man challenge would be 10 points for the win and 1 point for everygame won
If challenge finishes 11 - 9 winning clan would get 10 + 11 = 21 points losing clan 9
If a 5 man challenge ended 6 - 4 winning clan would get 5 + 6 = 11 points losing clan 4
Draws would be just games won