17 Nov 19
@mchill saidThat’s a beautiful rendition, by the way.
For years I've heard rumors Paul Simon copied this from somewhere. Sorry if I'm about 700 years late with this-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgbo2QWLBzI
I have little doubt that this originates from a Medieval folk ballad. Simon likely adapted it in the same manner that troubadours have covered ballads such as “Barbara Allen” and Robert Burns’ “My Love is Like a Red, Red Rose”.
These days we might say that he covered it, but since it’s in the public domain, he’s likely exempted from copyright laws or the ethical dilemmas of plagiarism. I’ve seen this done a lot with the remaking of Greek plays, with literary magnates such as Goethe and Shakespeare taking literary licenses.
As the prophets have said, “There is nothing new under the sun.” 😊
23 Nov 19
@mister-moggy saidSometimes a student overtops his master. Not in this case, however.
@hakima
i copy my posts from VR,
he and lemondrop are my inspiration.
gotta say it.. gotta love it.
24 Nov 19
@hakima saidI just wanted to say that I am glad you're on this site. 🙂
That’s a beautiful rendition, by the way.
I have little doubt that this originates from a Medieval folk ballad. Simon likely adapted it in the same manner that troubadours have covered ballads such as “Barbara Allen” and Robert Burns’ “My Love is Like a Red, Red Rose”.
These days we might say that he covered it, but since it’s in the public domain, he’s likely exempted f ...[text shortened]... eare taking literary licenses.
As the prophets have said, “There is nothing new under the sun.” 😊
You add a touch of class to the forums and this is so desperately needed.