05 Aug '08 20:46>
Originally posted by CeSingeThe only assumption is that the presenter will never open the door with the car in it when you haven't made your final selection. That's not an invalid assumption since that's exactly the way the show "Let's make a deal" worked - the host was Monty Hall and hence why it's called the Monty Hall problem.
In all replies I read here, assumptions are made that the presenter will this or would that. In the initial question, there is no hint towards such assumptions.
In such a case, your adds are 50%, and they are independent of the presenter and of the door you then choose (out of 2).
If this is incorrect, I'd be glad to hear it and understand why.
Beyo ...[text shortened]... presenter when opening a door, and doing so, you can modify the outcome of the problem at will.
The game worked by the contestant choosing one door. Then Monty would open a door showing the non-car item. Then he'd ask you whether you wanted to keep your choice or switch. There isn't any real assumption other than that he wouldn't open the door with the car first - which would ruin the game anyways.
The odds do work out to be better if you switch as people who have posted have explained and it is unintuitive to most. That's why so many people got goats on the show 🙂