vote on recommendation vs. thumbs

I suggest to set up a vote. The two thesis could be:

* The "new" unlimited thumbs up/down scheme should remain in place.

* the previous "recommend" (10 per month) should come back.

Opinions?

Originally posted by Ponderable
I suggest to set up a vote. The two thesis could be:

* The "new" unlimited thumbs up/down scheme should remain in place.

* the previous "recommend" (10 per month) should come back.

Opinions?

yes a vote would be good

Originally posted by Silverstriker
yes a vote would be good

Agreed. How can we organise it?

Originally posted by Kewpie
Agreed. How can we organise it?

First we need a chairperson, then we need a proposer and seconder. Then someone to take minutes and someone else to thumb them down.

Originally posted by divegeester
First we need a chairperson, then we need a proposer and seconder. Then someone to take minutes and someone else to thumb them down.

I nominate Grampy Bobby.

Originally posted by Ponderable
I suggest to set up a vote. The two thesis could be:

* The "new" unlimited thumbs up/down scheme should remain in place.

* the previous "recommend" (10 per month) should come back.

Opinions?

Is there some reason you want to limit my voice/vote/opinion?

Keep unlimited thumbs. Mouse-over a thumb shows who thumbed it up or down.

The thumb system lacks both intellectual accountability and discriminatory restraint, which means it is virtually valueless. Improvement requires either SG's idea of a mouse-over reveal or if not that, then a limit on the number permitted. Edit: preferably option one.

Make the thumb grow the more you get... if you get more than 20 thumbs, the thumb is so big it fills the screen.

This is the only change required.