02 Jan '08 14:30>
Originally posted by scottishinnz1) Interesting; my doubts started in my teens though I can't say I was a particulary devout believer as a child (such a thing is rare but not unknown). I still think that most atheists start as theists and then adopt an atheist position based on their evaluation of the "evidence" (such that it is).
No. I was never a theist, at least not after the age of about 6.
I am not saying that all theists are irrational. However, those which do not accept the fundamental proposition that they may be wrong cannot be debated in a meaningful way, since they are not prepared to meaningfully accept that your points may be valid if they contradict the ...[text shortened]...
Of course, I accept that my position may be wrong, but I don't think it is (rather obviously).
2) Do you think that is a common attribute of theists? Sometimes I think that being on this board, which is dominated by a particulary rabid form of minority Christianity leads one to conclusions about most theists that are unwarranted. Your paragraph, is of course, a circular argument.
3) Of course but why did you think other people don't share the same mindset?