Go back
Jehovah’s Witnesses and the Question of Blood

Jehovah’s Witnesses and the Question of Blood

Spirituality


https://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1101977010

A couple here have no concept of God's view on blood. If anyone else wants to learn more on God's views and commands about blood, this will explain this subject very clearly....


"Halal food is that which adheres to Islamic law, as defined in the Koran. The Islamic form of slaughtering animals or poultry, dhabiha, involves killing through a cut to the jugular vein, carotid artery and windpipe. Animals must be alive and healthy at the time of slaughter and all blood is drained from the carcass." BBC website

It's another perspective on what is, supposedly, "God's view on blood".

1 edit

@galveston75 said
A couple here have no concept of God's view on blood.
A "couple here"?

Surely it's more than a couple of people here who do not see it your way, right?

Which Christians here do you perceive as agreeing with your assertions about "God's view on blood" and blood transfusions?

Now that robbie carrobie and roigam are no longer posting, it's only you - I think - who believes that your God figure forbids blood transfusions.

I am willing to be corrected on this.


The symbolism of Jesus giving his blood by laying down his life to save humanity appears to run into somewhat of the cognitive dissonance buzz saw of doctrinaire myopia [without credible scriptural support, lest we forget] when people giving blood to save the lives of their fellow humans is condemned as "sinful".


@fmf said
It's another perspective on what is, supposedly, "God's view on blood".
Here is an interesting answer by a Muslim to the following question on Quora: "What happens if and when a Muslim needs a blood transfusion? Does he get Muslim blood or blood from anybody?"

"Blood has no faith. Blood is blood. There is no specification in the religion regarding blood transfusion donors to a Muslim must be Muslim; Therefore, it is assumed there is no such restrictions regarding the issue."

I wonder whether there are Christians who feel they should get their blood transfusions from fellow Christians.


@galveston75 said
https://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1101977010

A couple here have no concept of God's view on blood. If anyone else wants to learn more on God's views and commands about blood, this will explain this subject very clearly....
I'm fairly certain that God didn't decide this just so his church could go around shunning other humans for not falling in line.

1 edit


1 edit

1 edit


@fmf said
I wonder whether there are Christians who feel they should get their blood transfusions from fellow Christians.
Never heard of it. And if I ever hear a Christian say such a thing I'll laugh in their face, then feel despondent over their lack of faith and maturity.


Vote Up
Vote Down

@suzianne said
I'm fairly certain that God didn't decide this just so his church could go around shunning other humans for not falling in line.
No of course Jehovah didn't make his followers and their congregations to " just go around and shun other humans'. Why would you think this as the bible says no such thing?
So it sounds like in your opinion that ones in the congregation that might do something wrong and would give no indication that they were not going to stop doing it and shows no remorse and would be a bad influence on the ones in the congregations, should not be disciplined or possibly removed if the elders see the need to do that to protect the congregation?
So maybe look it up in the bible to see what Jehovah expects. The link I gave here goes into this in detail. Maybe you could get your bible out to compare what this link says in your bible?


@galveston75 said
No of course Jehovah didn't make his followers and their congregations to " just go around and shun other humans'. Why would you think this as the bible says no such thing?
So it sounds like in your opinion that ones in the congregation that might do something wrong and would give no indication that they were not going to stop doing it and shows no remorse and would be ...[text shortened]... e disciplined or possibly removed if the elders see the need to do that to protect the congregation?
Are you pleased that beaurobert's wife is still alive?

2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down