23 Nov '07 22:47>
Commentators have pondered this through the history of the game.
Do you believe the cricketers of today are pampered by manicured well grassed pitches. How about the bouncer? Should it return to it's former glory or was it a pain watching the West Indies teams of the 70's pounding them down at Batsmen all day? Would Ponting be where he is today?
All good food for thought as you select and we chat about our dream test twelve with a 13th pick for a turning wicket.
How should a dream test team be balanced? five top Bats 5 top bowlers?
Do we need specialists? Would you open with the top bats who never opened.. not for me but worth thinking about.
I've picked and revised re-picked and revised this team several times and think I've balanced my personal favs with averages and with todays players and the players of the great 60s-80s era.
I've picked for the rules of the 70's too.. I hate the way the game has been tamed today.
Think about touring with your team to the dirt tracks and grassy mine fields as well as the flat tracks
1. Bradman D .. The Don is the greatest in history
2. Pollack R.G. .. only 23 tests over 60 av..
3. Ponting R .. The greatest living batsman
4. Richards V .. Terminator
5. Sobers G .. Sir Garfield "First Knight" magic!
6. Gilchrist A .. Instant promotion if an opener fails
7. Khan I .. Best Bowling all-rounder ever.
8. Warne S .. Love him or hate him
9. Hadlee R .. Mr NZ Cricket.. superb craftsman
10. Marshall M .. The mainstay of WI's golden era
11. McGrath G ... very close.. just gets in ahead of Curtly Ambrose (lazy but less prone to injury) would pick Muralitharan on turning wkt.
12. Rhodes J ... fastest off the ground thrower of the ball I have ever seen and one of the most rapid athletic mid-fielders I've seen.
I've picked for ability to dominate and change the game. Each individual player here could win or turn a game.. they all did on many occasions.
Do you believe the cricketers of today are pampered by manicured well grassed pitches. How about the bouncer? Should it return to it's former glory or was it a pain watching the West Indies teams of the 70's pounding them down at Batsmen all day? Would Ponting be where he is today?
All good food for thought as you select and we chat about our dream test twelve with a 13th pick for a turning wicket.
How should a dream test team be balanced? five top Bats 5 top bowlers?
Do we need specialists? Would you open with the top bats who never opened.. not for me but worth thinking about.
I've picked and revised re-picked and revised this team several times and think I've balanced my personal favs with averages and with todays players and the players of the great 60s-80s era.
I've picked for the rules of the 70's too.. I hate the way the game has been tamed today.
Think about touring with your team to the dirt tracks and grassy mine fields as well as the flat tracks
1. Bradman D .. The Don is the greatest in history
2. Pollack R.G. .. only 23 tests over 60 av..
3. Ponting R .. The greatest living batsman
4. Richards V .. Terminator
5. Sobers G .. Sir Garfield "First Knight" magic!
6. Gilchrist A .. Instant promotion if an opener fails
7. Khan I .. Best Bowling all-rounder ever.
8. Warne S .. Love him or hate him
9. Hadlee R .. Mr NZ Cricket.. superb craftsman
10. Marshall M .. The mainstay of WI's golden era
11. McGrath G ... very close.. just gets in ahead of Curtly Ambrose (lazy but less prone to injury) would pick Muralitharan on turning wkt.
12. Rhodes J ... fastest off the ground thrower of the ball I have ever seen and one of the most rapid athletic mid-fielders I've seen.
I've picked for ability to dominate and change the game. Each individual player here could win or turn a game.. they all did on many occasions.