Young Potential Hall of Famers

Guys in their first 3 years that you think have Hall of Fame written on them.

Tim Lincecum
Josh Hamilton

Lincecum has 18 career wins. Josh Hamilton has 204 career hits. Can we hold off a bit on Hall of Fame talk? Last year you would have named Troy Tulowitzki (who may still be great) but it is a bit dumb just guessing now.

I'm not touching this thread... 3 years? Waaaay too hard to tell...

Ryan Howard
Chase Utley

- I'm a homer

Originally posted by uzless
Guys in their first 3 years that you think have Hall of Fame written on them.

Tim Lincecum
Josh Hamilton

Actually Josh Hamilton is not in his first 3 years. He was drafted I think in 2000 or 2001 and was out of baseball for 3 years due to his addictions.

Originally posted by JohnLennonForever
Actually Josh Hamilton is not in his first 3 years. He was drafted I think in 2000 or 2001 and was out of baseball for 3 years due to his addictions.

ug, first real year....will that do?

Originally posted by darvlay
I'm not touching this thread... 3 years? Waaaay too hard to tell...

what??? something you DON'T have an opinion on? Come on Darv...yer gettin soft

Originally posted by jofaz
Lincecum has 18 career wins. Josh Hamilton has 204 career hits. Can we hold off a bit on Hall of Fame talk? Last year you would have named Troy Tulowitzki (who may still be great) but it is a bit dumb just guessing now.

The SPorts forum is devoid of anything substantial...just like the Culture Forum.

Why don't you add a Thread worth discussing instead of complaining then?

Originally posted by uzless
The SPorts forum is devoid of anything substantial...just like the Culture Forum.

Why don't you add a Thread worth discussing instead of complaining then?

I am not complaining. But I think you completely trivialize what it means to be an all time great when you talk about guys who have play a (singular) season.

Evan Longoria