If it's proven there's no god

Joined: 26 Aug 07
Moves: 38239

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by FMF
So it's only the choices made homosexual men [b]who have contracted HIV that you are declaring immoral? Is this not a shift from your stance earlier on this thread when you were declaring ALL homosexual acts immoral?[/b]

this is mere pedantry at its worse.

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Perhaps, but i need to go shopping, ill think about this.

Well?

googlefudge

Joined: 31 May 06
Moves: 1795

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
No not at this time.

Then you are guilty of "Special Pleading", a logical fallacy.

You are claiming some special rules apply to this one case without any justification for doing so.

Proper Knob

Cornovii

North of the Tamar

Joined: 02 Feb 07
Moves: 53689

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
No not at this time.

Give it some thought.

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
this is mere pedantry at its worse.

You are now talking about your moral pronouncement applying to "homosexual men living in the UK who had contracted HIV"; this is a complete shift from you'd been saying for pages after page of this thread.

Joined: 26 Aug 07
Moves: 38239

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by Proper Knob
Give it some thought.

No I am thinking about something else but it requires a new thread.

Joined: 26 Aug 07
Moves: 38239

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by googlefudge
Then you are guilty of "Special Pleading", a logical fallacy.

You are claiming some special rules apply to this one case without any justification for doing so.

Special pleading? I've never heard of that, cool, will check it out.

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

21 Apr 15

If this were robbie up on the stage giving a talk on morality, he'd now have to pretend the microphone suddenly wasn't working and then "sadly" bring his presentation to an end before he could answer any more questions. 😵

Joined: 26 Aug 07
Moves: 38239

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by FMF
If this were robbie up on the stage giving a talk on morality, he'd now have to pretend the microphone suddenly wasn't working and then "sadly" bring his presentation to an end before he could answer any more questions. 😵

I am under no duress to answer any questions FMF.

Joined: 28 Oct 05
Moves: 34587

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I am under no duress to answer any questions FMF.

I doubt anyone expects much from you.

Joined: 26 Aug 07
Moves: 38239

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by FMF
I doubt anyone expects much from you.

least of all me 😀

Suzianne

Misfit Queen

Isle of Misfit Toys

Joined: 08 Aug 03
Moves: 36705

21 Apr 15

I don't suppose you two could get a room?

Joined: 26 Aug 07
Moves: 38239

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by Suzianne
I don't suppose you two could get a room?

try making friends, it not so hard 😀

sonhouse

Fast and Curious

slatington, pa, usa

Joined: 28 Dec 04
Moves: 53223

21 Apr 15

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
try making friends, it not so hard 😀

I wonder if FMF plays guitar?

Joined: 26 Aug 07
Moves: 38239

21 Apr 15

2 edits