One Queen Beats Two Queens

One Queen Beats Two Queens

The Planet Greenpawn

One Queen Beats Two Queens

A great man once wrote:

“One thing leads to another.”

I’ve no idea who it was. I used to know but one thing led to another
and I’ve forgotten, But who ever he was he was right.

I’ve been thumbing through;

Battle of Ideas

Saidy mentioned a Reshevsky’s part in the 1948 World Championship.
My mind recalled Reshevsky missed a win v Botvinnik.
So, find the missed win, look for examples of similar missed wins in RHP
and there is a blog theme.

So I find Reshevsky’s best games, open up the book and the word ‘trap’
leaps out at me. ‘An ingenious trap’ writes Reshevsky.

Who is this who sets ‘ingenious traps’ I ask myself and I discover it is none
other than Capablanca!

Well, well, well. How charming is that?
I set traps and get called a caveman, Capablanca does it and is called a genius.

I like showing Capa traps because a lot of previous writers babble on
on that Capa never stooped to such low levels of play.
Of course he did, except his had that touch of class, though I have to admit
as a top trap setter this one is rather transparent.

Here is the trap. Reshevsky - Capablanca, Margate 1935

Capa had been under the cosh for most of the middle game defending a backward
b-pawn. He missed a good chance to complicate things but let that moment slip by
and was left with a really awkward position to hold. (if indeed he can be held.)

Capa must have known he would be seeking a trap or two to get him
out of trouble, because first he offered a draw which was politely declined.

If I was writing this in the 1930’s I could add another Capa myth.

Capablanca Myth No.112

“Before lowering the tone of a game by setting traps Capablanca would first
offer a draw. Only if it was declined would he then set ingenious traps.”

Anyway one thing was leading to another so I found the Botvinnik game.

It was Reshevsky - Botvinnik AVRO 1938.

My mind was playing traps on me! It not 1948, but 1938.

Botvinnik, according to Reshevsky’s notes, was coasting to a win but allowed
him to complicate matters by giving up his Queen for two Rooks.
This appeared on the board.

So where is this leading?
RHP games where two Rooks beat a Queen?

The Duck
Nah GP. That's a naff idea.

So I log onto RHP and see someone has sent me a game.
‘One Queen beats Two Queens’ is the title.

And one thing led to another.

HikaruShindo -jaryvan RHP November 2012

So thanks to HikaruShindo we have a theme for this weeks blog.
Players becoming mesmerized by the prospect of having two Queens.

rooki - bbmo2001 RHP 2010 will give you the idea.

midknight - derbrad RHP 2007

darksideofthemoonie - 2advent RHP 2010

What a game Look at this position after Black’s 43rd move.

And 50 gruelling moves later we reach here.

Black has fought off White’s attempts at perpetual check and
is now on the brink of winning.
This is where you will chuck most won games. When you are on the brink of
winning you are also on the brink of blunderland. Never forget that.

mikenay - Wiabj RHP 2007

Another example of the promoting player slipping into relaxed mode.

And finally for a complete change…

I came across this in 'Kings, Commoners and Knaves' by Edward Winter.
It's a position from a game by two unknown players in the British Chess
Magazine March 1907.

The thread accompanying this blog is Thread 149765

Posted to The Planet Greenpawn

Show Comments (7)
Comments (7)

  • Posted 2294 days 4 hours and 39 minutes ago
    Still can't believe I'm on the blog!
  • Posted 2484 days and 20 minutes ago
    Standard memberROLL TIDE ROLL
    two of RHP's big dogs in a one queen beats two queens game: bulletGame id 9366028
  • Posted 2513 days 23 hours and 4 minutes ago
    Standard memberbibbchess
    Here's another 2 queener succumbing to perpetual check.

    Game 9282424
  • Posted 2570 days 19 hours and 9 minutes ago
    Standard memberkaspan
    Great blog as usual GP! Your blogs are getting better over time unlike my game ๐Ÿ™‚ After a marathon game I relaxed a bit, made an absolute end game blunder and handed over the game (Game # 9542356) this blog and the advice was just that.....not to drop guard in won position ๐Ÿ™‚
  • Posted 2573 days 11 hours and 2 minutes ago
    Standard memberjcmessy
    I like your blog man. keep it up..
  • Posted 2576 days 1 hour and 57 minutes ago
    Post it in the chess forum, there are quite a few good lads
    there who will help.
  • Posted 2576 days 6 hours and 59 minutes ago
    Standard memberilovephill
    1. d4 d5 2. c4 e6 3. Nb1c3 Ng8f6 4. cxd5 exd5 5. e3 Bf8b4 6. Bf1d3 O-O 7. Ng1e2 b6 8. a3 Bb4d6 9. Qd1c2 Nb8d7 10. Nc3b5 Nf6e4 11. Bd3xe4 dxe4 12. Qc2xe4 Bc8a6 13. Qe4c6 Nd7f6 14. Bc1d2 Qd8e7 15. Nb5c3 Rf8e8 16. Ra1c1 Qe7e6 17. Nc3b5 Nf6g4 18. Nb5xc7 Qe6f6 19. h3 Qf6xf2 20. Ke1d1 Qf2xe2 21. Kd1c2 Qe2d3 22. Kc2d1 Ng4f2 23. Kd1e1 Qd3e2 0-1 could you do an analysis on this game please man for me
    Last Post
    06 Dec '19
    Blog since
    06 Jul '10