If you recently completed a game, it takes a while for the server to catch up with this. This situation has existed for some time and comes up regularly. I don't know if this will ever be addressed by the admin. folks or not.
So for now all you can do is give it a little more time and then try again.....
Originally posted by AIMaster Unless I can't count, there are just 5 games under "My Games", so there must be a bug in the system...
A bug seems the most likely case doesn't it?
There's another possibility: you might have archived a game before it finished, so it doesn't appear on your "My Games" page.
If you go to "My games", the select "My archives", check that all the games in there are indeed over.
Its an unlikely cause I'll admit but you never know till you try!