Go back
Chess 960

Chess 960

Only Chess

n
Ronin

Hereford Boathouse

Joined
08 Oct 09
Moves
29575
Clock
26 Jul 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Would the modern greats have an edge over the old masters? Could a guy like Svidler crush Morphy?

g

Joined
20 Jul 10
Moves
1072
Clock
26 Jul 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

I just started up my time machine, I'll go get Morphy and we'll settle this once and for all!

g

Joined
20 Jul 10
Moves
1072
Clock
26 Jul 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

I just got back and Morphy said "G.F.Y"

M

Joined
16 Oct 09
Moves
2448
Clock
26 Jul 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

That would probably be the best way to compare everyone's skill! I think the modern players would have an edge in the endings, but Morphy would win it out of the opening!

r
the walrus

an English garden

Joined
15 Jan 08
Moves
32836
Clock
26 Jul 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Maxacre42
That would probably be the best way to compare everyone's skill! I think the modern players would have an edge in the endings, but Morphy would win it out of the opening!
I doubt it. Opening theory isn't the only thing that has evolved since Morphy's time. Every aspect of Svidler's game is probably stronger but Morphy had more natural talent.

s

Joined
17 Mar 08
Moves
1568
Clock
26 Jul 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Yes Svidler would certainly beat Morphy even without opening theory.
The lack of strong opposition prevented Morphy to get to the level of today's elite.

Maybe at chess 960 he would equal player around 2600? hard to tell
But of course if he had the opportunity to get the training of modern masters, it would be a different matter.

n
Ronin

Hereford Boathouse

Joined
08 Oct 09
Moves
29575
Clock
27 Jul 10
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

First off, Svidler is one of the big natural talents of the last 20 years..
Endings and defensive skills are much higher now, but I am not even sure how much that would matter in 960.


and Morphy would say "get away from my shoe collection!"

greenpawn34

e4

Joined
06 May 08
Moves
43363
Clock
27 Jul 10
Vote Up
Vote Down

Morphy would take one look at the set up and say;

"What games is this? It's not Chess."

He would then kick over board and demand to be taken back to the 1800's.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.