The selected position is I think not at it's critical moment.
That moment happened just a few moves before.
In the game White played 44.Nf3 Rxd4 45 Nxd4 taking it to the posted position.
I think here is an important crossroad.
I always look at these things with a 'what would I do OTB' view.
(and then create a wee OTB situation. Today it's a league match, tomorrow
maybe a fight for the heavy weight crown, next week an off hand game
v a complete stranger in a pub.)
Surprised (but then again no) that RJ tried to evaluate it using the point system
(Rook =5 Bishop =3 etc.). It's not one them positions where ROTs help.
Black's last move in the posted postion was Rxd4 (giving up a 5 for a 3)
is just one example how misleading the point system is.
It's what you feel, see and have experience with.
I'm not liking White, if that Bishop gets out it will be at least be equal to a Rook
(that is a Bishop = 5 pts RJ.)
If the Bishop gets out then the White f6 pawn has to fall and then the
those Kingside pawns look a real menance.
Black will be chopping that Bishop on d4. He has too. It's a good move.
Then I am looking at that posted position (in my mind)
And I'm not liking that at all.
All the winning chances are with Black, White (me) will have to play some
pretty exact moves to draw it . (and this is me in an ending) 🙁
Sac the Knight for the Queenside pawns, the Rook will pick up the d-pawn
when the Bishop takes the Knight.
Bishop and three connected pawns v a Rook.
He has the wrong Bishop for the h-pawn....
That Gulfeld game where a Bishop and 3 pawns outplayed 2 Rooks.
Remember the Rooks offering themselves for free to the Bishop 'please take me'
and the Bishop refusing to take them.
(experience and what you have seen are better than ROTs, sometimes
they too can lead or influence you the wrong way but I'd rather go with those
than a Rook = 5 etc.... )
No. OTB me (and it helps greatly if you know yourself.)
I would not see the posted position.
I'm transfixed by not letting the Bishop out.
(again that me. I see an idea and sometimes simply refuse to let it go.)
There is a plausible, easy to see trick, tuck inside is a not so easy to see trick.
(based on OTB experience and the blunders players make.)
So not exact analysis. I'm not White playing a GM.
I'm White playing a normal Joe in a league match in a club room next to a disco.
You have to be honest with yourself in these sistuations.
There is more chance of me playing working class Joe in the above conditions
than me playing a GM with more TD's than there are players.
[FEN "2R4b/5p1k/3p1Pp1/p6p/1p1B1K2/8/3r4/4N3 w - - 0 1"]
1. Ba1 {Black is not getting the d4 Bishop so the h8 Bshop stays in it's hole.} 1... Rd1 {A rook fork. This was anticipated.} 2. Nf3 {If now RxB then Ng5+ and Rxh8 is mate. That will put the frightners on him. Never underestimate the frightners. OTB the frightners win games. That by the way was trap one.} 2... Rf1 {Pinning the Knight with g5+ coming.} 3. Kg3 {This is trap 2. Taking away the threatend mate because the King no longer holds the Knight on g5. Black a piece down and a Bishop stuck on h8 has a choice. Allow the perpetual or play on....} 3... Rxa1 {Black goes for the perpetual.} 4. Ng5+ Kh6 5. Nxf7+ Kh7 6. Ng5+ {Perpetual check yes?} 6... Kh6 7. Nf7+ Kh7 8. Rxh8# {Actually no. White Mates. And having seen that I would have gone for it. In the cold light of day you can see the holes. OTB with a clock ticking, music being played next door, a game being discussed at the back of the room,.....that would have happened.}
Sorry Danilop, my contribution was no help what so ever.
Keep bumping up the thread eventually someone will run it through an engine
and you will get x amount of moves that would never see the light of day
in the real world.
Good post though, my team won the league match and in the pub afterwards
I pulled this gorgeous blonde, we ran off to Holland together.
I'm in Holland now typing this......I can log onto Chesscube. 🙂