Critique

Critique

Only Chess

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
14 Mar 07

I just won a 3-0 game in the Pirc on PC, and since I'm new to this opening (Plan on using it mostly against 1.d4) I wanted to know how my play was overall, especially in the opening. Be as critical as you like...

[Event "Rated game, 3m + 0s"]
[Site "Main Playing Hall"]
[Date "2007.03.13"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Chess nut"]
[Black "CMSMaster"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "B08"]
[WhiteElo "1448"]
[BlackElo "1409"]
[PlyCount "82"]
[EventDate "2007.03.13"]
[TimeControl "180"]

1. e4 {5} d6 {1} 2. d4 {2} Nf6 {1} 3. Nc3 {5} g6 {1} 4. Nf3 {4} Bg7 {1} 5. Be2
{5} O-O {1} 6. h3 {5} c6 {1} 7. Be3 {3} b5 {1} 8. a3 {2} Nbd7 {2} 9. Qd2 {1}
Bb7 {2} 10. Bh6 {3} a5 {2} 11. Bxg7 {2} Kxg7 {1} 12. O-O {8} b4 {2} 13. axb4 {3
} axb4 {1} 14. Rxa8 {2} Qxa8 {2} 15. Nb1 {22} Nxe4 {17} 16. Qxb4 {4} c5 {8} 17.
dxc5 {7} Nexc5 {1} 18. Qc4 {13} Ba6 {3} 19. Qd4+ {12} Nf6 {12} 20. Bxa6 {2}
Qxa6 {2} 21. Re1 {6} Re8 {5} 22. b4 {4} Ne6 {4} 23. Qd3 {4} Qxd3 {2} 24. cxd3 {
3} Rb8 {2} 25. Rc1 {4} Rxb4 {4} 26. Nbd2 {7} Rb7 {3} 27. Ne4 {2} Nxe4 {2} 28.
dxe4 {2} Rc7 {1} 29. Rxc7 {5} Nxc7 {1} 30. Kf1 {1} d5 {2} 31. exd5 {2} Nxd5 {1}
32. Ke2 {1} Nf4+ {1} 33. Kf1 {4} Kf6 {3} 34. h4 {4} Kf5 {4} 35. g3 {1} Ne6 {2}
36. Kg2 {5} Kg4 {1} 37. Nh2+ {2} Kh5 {2} 38. Kh3 {3} Kh6 {2} 39. g4 {3} Kg7 {1}
40. f3 {2} f5 {2} 41. g5 {3} h6 {Time (Lag: Av=0.41s, max=1.0s) . 2} 0-1

(BTW:I do see the king + pawn fork by the knight for white at move 37, in time pressure I missed it.)

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
14 Mar 07

Meh your defence against his modern set-up wasn't very active..but your oppenant was more worried about trading your dark square bishop then playing in the center, which would have caused you a more serious problem

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
14 Mar 07

Forgot to add in 10.e5, would be more active then whites plan

v

Joined
04 Jul 06
Moves
7174
14 Mar 07

Originally posted by cmsMaster
I just won a 3-0 game in the Pirc on PC, and since I'm new to this opening (Plan on using it mostly against 1.d4) I wanted to know how my play was overall, especially in the opening. Be as critical as you like...

[Event "Rated game, 3m + 0s"]
[Site "Main Playing Hall"]
[Date "2007.03.13"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Chess nut"]
[Black "CMSMaster"]
[Resul ...[text shortened]... rk by the knight for white at move 37, in time pressure I missed it.)
Pirc against 1d4 ?
I thought it is called KID.

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
14 Mar 07
1 edit

Originally posted by vipiu
Pirc against 1d4 ?
I thought it is called KID.
1.d4 d6 2.e4 is a Pirc

1.d4 d6 2.c4 e5!? isn't either.

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
14 Mar 07

Originally posted by Restless Soul
Meh your defence against his modern set-up wasn't very active..but your oppenant was more worried about trading your dark square bishop then playing in the center, which would have caused you a more serious problem
Any suggestions on moves where I should have played something that I didn't?

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
14 Mar 07

Originally posted by Restless Soul
Forgot to add in 10.e5, would be more active then whites plan
12.e5 is better,

10.e5 dxe5 11.dxe5 Nd5 12.Nxd5 cxd5 13.Bd4 Qc7 and black's doing ok.

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
14 Mar 07

Originally posted by cmsMaster
Any suggestions on moves where I should have played something that I didn't?
Well in the classical version black usually plays e5 before white can push it, also before you castled another line for black is bg4 and nc6, the fight is for the d4 square

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
14 Mar 07

Originally posted by cmsMaster
12.e5 is better,

10.e5 dxe5 11.dxe5 Nd5 12.Nxd5 cxd5 13.Bd4 Qc7 and black's doing ok.
Looking at it closer instead of Qd2, e5 would have been better..e5 is usually whites main move in most lines of the pirc

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
15 Mar 07

Not to drag this out, but why did you play c6 instead of a6?

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
15 Mar 07

Originally posted by Restless Soul
Not to drag this out, but why did you play c6 instead of a6?
c6 is a playable move there, it's book actually.

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
15 Mar 07

new to me -.-..a6 has proven to give black good chances, keeping his c pawn there in case a chance for a c5 push comes around...the only thing that sucks for black the modern with an early h3 is black plans are often limited, but white has to counter all them..as nimzo used to say..."The threat is often greater then the execution"..or somethin like that

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
15 Mar 07

Originally posted by Restless Soul
new to me -.-..a6 has proven to give black good chances, keeping his c pawn there in case a chance for a c5 push comes around...the only thing that sucks for black the modern with an early h3 is black plans are often limited, but white has to counter all them..as nimzo used to say..."The threat is often greater then the execution"..or somethin like that
Yeah, a6 and Bg4 are both very common also. I got my move from a learning DB, it says about c6...

The idea of blacks move is to free c7 for his queen and to prepare the e7-e5 advance at the same time.

White's most common responses:

7.Rf1
7.Bf4
7.h3
7.a4

Then black has to respond to those, but 7...Nbd7 is playable against any one of those - 6...c6 doesn't have too much theory to worry about.