Go back
Giving Advice During a Game

Giving Advice During a Game

Only Chess

M

Joined
06 Nov 13
Moves
0
Clock
06 Nov 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Hello guys,
Recently in a chess game in the chess club I was in, my opponent had a couple people giving him advice (It was a regular club chess game) on more then a few movements he could take through out the mid game and into the later portion of the game which helped him win. I was wondering if this generally viewed as bad mannerism when playing a game of chess.

MC

Joined
08 Aug 09
Moves
708
Clock
06 Nov 13

Originally posted by MacGregor93
Hello guys,
Recently in a chess game in the chess club I was in, my opponent had a couple people giving him advice (It was a regular club chess game) on more then a few movements he could take through out the mid game and into the later portion of the game which helped him win. I was wondering if this generally viewed as bad mannerism when playing a game of chess.
It most certainly is unless you have agreed to it beforehand. Chess is a game played between two people not three.

FL

Joined
21 Feb 06
Moves
6830
Clock
06 Nov 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

That would be regarded as cheating at any club I've ever belonged to.

Sometimes this happens in offhand games, but even then my opponent will usually say something like "you've won this one" (i.e. not quite resign!) and then ask an observer for advice to see if, working together, they could turn it around. On the odd occasion when someone has sought advice in an equal / unclear position I've just resigned and refused a rematch.

moon1969

Houston, Texas

Joined
28 Sep 10
Moves
14347
Clock
06 Nov 13

Originally posted by MacGregor93
Hello guys,
Recently in a chess game in the chess club I was in, my opponent had a couple people giving him advice (It was a regular club chess game) on more then a few movements he could take through out the mid game and into the later portion of the game which helped him win. I was wondering if this generally viewed as bad mannerism when playing a game of chess.
You could look at it as a challenge to beat a team of players as your opponent, or you could refuse to play.

thaughbaer
Duckfinder General

223b Baker Street

Joined
25 Apr 06
Moves
33101
Clock
07 Nov 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Politely explain that you don't have any friends and get out your computer saying "What's the difference ?". Unless of course you already have a computer in your shoes.

C
Cowboy From Hell

American West

Joined
19 Apr 10
Moves
55013
Clock
07 Nov 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by MISTER CHESS
It most certainly is unless you have agreed to it beforehand. Chess is a game played between two people not three.
Spot on

H

Joined
04 Nov 08
Moves
21841
Clock
07 Nov 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Always bad manners without invitation. However on club nights with friends if a better player sees a clearly losing move it can be instructive if they explain with alternatives.
In a friendly club there can be implied consent to assistance.

KellerBulldog

Joined
08 Oct 10
Moves
24783
Clock
17 Nov 13
Vote Up
Vote Down

Bad manners and illegal. Some tournament directors/arbiters will kick the player who heard the advise and the adviser from the tournament. Most players at the tournament know this and refrain. At a club match, it's just terrible manners.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.