Go back
Is it true about Black?

Is it true about Black?

Only Chess

slickhare
...

Santa Clara, CA

Joined
02 Oct 06
Moves
9225
Clock
06 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

I've been told that at the epitome of skill, Black can only hope to draw against White. So does this mean that all wins as Black are technically flukes?

v

Joined
25 Jun 05
Moves
44884
Clock
06 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

No.

d

Joined
29 Mar 07
Moves
1260
Clock
06 May 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

I think the idea is that chess must theoratically be a forced draw by black, if played perfectly by two sides, white being the "attacker". like a drawn white pawn-up endgame, if you see what I mean. so if black loses, it's a little less surprising.

by the way, in opening theory, good moves for black are suggested by the terms "...and black equalizes", and for white, "white keeps the slight edge".

G

Stockholm, Sweden

Joined
31 Jan 06
Moves
3059
Clock
06 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

While the game is probably theoretically a draw, white normally takes the opening advantage which means "better chances" / "easier play", but an advantage does not always mean it's a theoretical win (I'd say it's more often the other way around).

MCA
TokerSmurf

Bonnie Scotland

Joined
16 Jun 04
Moves
15683
Clock
06 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Golub
... an advantage does not always mean it's a theoretical win ...
This is very true - most players have drawn or even lost games even though being significantly ahead in material.

"advantages" can be very deceiving.

S
Lead, Follow, or..

Saint Petersburg, FL

Joined
17 Aug 06
Moves
135533
Clock
06 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

If you're looking at black as a defense, it's a veto. It only takes one bad move on your opponent's part to put black on the offense. All of the sudden, the game changes.

R
The Rams

Joined
04 Sep 06
Moves
13491
Clock
06 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

There is no "perfect" play in chess. Every move has some sort of setback or at least every 1-3 moves.

d

Joined
13 Feb 04
Moves
23476
Clock
06 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by slickhare
I've been told that at the epitome of skill, Black can only hope to draw against White. So does this mean that all wins as Black are technically flukes?
If so, then a white win is a technical fluke, too.

g

Joined
22 Aug 06
Moves
359
Clock
08 May 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Every decisive game in chess history that reached an "over-the-board" conclusion (e.g. the loss wasn't the result of a time forfiet or something like that unrelated to the position on the board)had at least one error by the loser. As GM Andrew Soltis once wrote, "Chess is not a game of good moves and better moves, it is a game of bad moves and worse moves." The point of Soltis' remark is that bad moves hurt you more than good moves help you. The only way for White to get a forced "mate in six" is for Black to make an error.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.