Is this bad?

Is this bad?

Only Chess

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
29 Mar 20

I have started playing this hoping to win a piece when black plays an early Bf5 . I am white.



Is it ok? Or should I continue developing normally?

D
Losing the Thread

Quarantined World

Joined
27 Oct 04
Moves
87415
29 Mar 20

3. ... Bf5 is pretty rare. Out of 27,000 games on my database reaching the position after 3. Nc3 it was played 121 times. The average ELO of the black players was 1,734. The two games with the strongest players were: Rajesh (2402) vs Vaibhav (2589) drawn and Holt (2534) vs Hernandez Carmer (2542) black win. Rajesh continued 4. Nf3 and Holt 4. e4.

Both 4. Nf3 and 4. Qb3 seem to score well, but the games are not between strong players.

The continuation 4. h4 does not appear on my database. So you've got surprise value anyway. I gave the position to Crafty, but only for about 20 seconds and after 3. ... Bf5 it gives the position as +0.75 going down to about +0.2 after 4. h4.

Based on this I think that 4. h4 is fine, it's certainly not instantly losing, it gets your opponent off any opening theory they might have. If you've got some tactical tricks to go with it I'm not seeing huge any reason not to play it.

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
29 Mar 20

I am shooting for something like this

e4

Joined
06 May 08
Moves
42492
29 Mar 20

I'm all in favour of players thinking of and trying out ideas, in fact I encourage it.
But here the risk of weakening the Kingside may prove too much. (see below)

Most 'new' opening ideas in the first few moves have been tried, some have
evolved into recognised variations, others relegated to Capablanca's dustbin.

Look for new ideas in recognised often seen openings from moves 8 - 10.
Something like delaying castling as Black in the Dragon v the Yugoslav Attack,
(very risky) but it saves a tempo for a Black Queenside push and White's
Kingside attack is hitting nothing and they may misplace a White piece or
make a needless (weakening) move on their Queenside.

In this day and age the ideas are more in general plans than one move bombs.


E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
29 Mar 20

Yeah, that looks really bad. Thanks for pointing it out. I while back I watched some videos by a gm doing what he called the polar bear opening and he showed this idea.

Secret RHP coder

on the payroll

Joined
26 Nov 04
Moves
155080
29 Mar 20
2 edits

@eladar said
I have started playing this hoping to win a piece when black plays an early Bf5 . I am white. [pgn][Event "Chessboard Editor at Apronus.com"]
[Site "https://www.apronus.com/chess/wbeditor.php"]
[Date "2020.03.28"]
[Round "-"]
[White "?"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "*"]

1. d4 d5 2. c4 c6 3. Nc3 Bf5 4. h4 *

[/pgn]

Is it ok? Or should I continue developing normally?
Reminds me of a favorite Caro Kann line:



Edit: a better way for black to play is:

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
29 Mar 20

@BigDoggProblem

That e5 push shuts down the dark bishop threat.

Secret RHP coder

on the payroll

Joined
26 Nov 04
Moves
155080
29 Mar 20

@eladar said
@BigDoggProblem

That e5 push shuts down the dark bishop threat.
Which threat is that?

E

Joined
12 Jul 08
Moves
13814
30 Mar 20

@bigdoggproblem said
Which threat is that?
The one green pawn demonstrated in his first board.