Go back
Opening

Opening

Only Chess

D
Chicago Maniac

Moon

Joined
14 Dec 07
Moves
19318
Clock
04 Jan 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

If I'm playing black and he goes d4 what's the best way to defend that? I've tried Scandanavian but he pushes his e4 pwn as well and now I'm in a hole.

Mctayto
Highlander

Planet Earth

Joined
10 Dec 04
Moves
1044663
Clock
04 Jan 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DaBearsFan08
If I'm playing black and he goes d4 what's the best way to defend that? I've tried Scandanavian but he pushes his e4 pwn as well and now I'm in a hole.
personally Nf6 options of K.Indian amongst other defences

duecer
anybody seen my

underpants??

Joined
01 Sep 06
Moves
56453
Clock
04 Jan 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

1...g6

MontyMoose

New Braunfels, Texas

Joined
22 Aug 07
Moves
72297
Clock
04 Jan 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DaBearsFan08
he goes d4 I've tried Scandanavian
Scandanavian is a defense against 1)e4 not d4.

JoL
Curb Your Enthusiasm

London

Joined
04 Nov 07
Moves
4259
Clock
04 Jan 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

JoL
Curb Your Enthusiasm

London

Joined
04 Nov 07
Moves
4259
Clock
04 Jan 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Hmmm.

My post just got bounced by the profanity checker for what I consider to be a very tame word.

Anyhoo, in short, there is no one best way to answer 1. d4. If there was chess would be a very dull game. It all comes down to personal taste and style.

My personal prefernce is 1. ... e6 (very flexible) or 1. ... d5. Occasionally if I'm feeling frisky I might play 1. ... Nf6

M

Earth

Joined
04 Aug 06
Moves
28872
Clock
04 Jan 08
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DaBearsFan08
If I'm playing black and he goes d4 what's the best way to defend that? I've tried Scandanavian but he pushes his e4 pwn as well and now I'm in a hole.
You have a range of options, hence you will get a range of answers.
If I told you that nearly 3 in 4 grandmaster games reply to d4 with Nf6, you might get the best start point. The aim is to prevent white getting both pawns in the centre by preventing e4 next. You can go any number of ways from here.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.