Go back
OTB Club Game

OTB Club Game

Only Chess

9

Joined
01 Feb 07
Moves
7819
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down



I played this game yesterday at the local club but haven't had a chance to analzye with an engine yet. I offered a draw because I was pretty low on time but does anyone see a winning line for Black here being up a pawn?

s

Joined
26 Nov 03
Moves
11918
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by 93confirmed
[fen]R5K1/5PPP/Q7/8/1q3r2/1p1Pp2p/1p4p1/1k6 b - - 0 1[/fen]

I played this game yesterday at the local club but haven't had a chance to analzye with an engine yet. I offered a draw because I was pretty low on time but does anyone see a winning line for Black here being up a pawn?
wow are you telling me white accepted a draw!? I would never have accepted a draw from that position (yes I realise that it must be black's move) as white, and I certainly would not expect white to offer a draw from what looks like very commanding position

9

Joined
01 Feb 07
Moves
7819
Clock
15 Mar 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by stevetodd
wow are you telling me white accepted a draw!? I would never have accepted a draw from that position (yes I realise that it must be black's move) as white, and I certainly would not expect white to offer a draw from what looks like very commanding position
Both sides have mate threats and after Qh5, I don't think White can win with this position. Maybe I'm missing something...

s

Joined
26 Nov 03
Moves
11918
Clock
15 Mar 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by 93confirmed
Both sides have mate threats and after Qh5, I don't think White can win with this position. Maybe I'm missing something...
after ...qh5 white advances his passed pawn! It means that black will loss his quenn (and his passed pawns) for only a rook and white's passed pawn

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by 93confirmed
Both sides have mate threats and after Qh5, I don't think White can win with this position. Maybe I'm missing something...
Qh5 would lose to e7

b
Best Loser

Traxler is Sound!

Joined
14 Nov 06
Moves
17862
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Restless Soul
Qh5 would lose to e7
why?.. can't the rook just help out?

o

Joined
15 Jul 06
Moves
1598
Clock
15 Mar 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by 93confirmed
Both sides have mate threats and after Qh5, I don't think White can win with this position. Maybe I'm missing something...
The position looks lost for black.
Qh5 e7 Kf7 e8=Q Kxe8 Qe6+ followed by Rxq, and I can't see any better defence for black.
Qh7 e7 Re5 fails to Qc8+

s

Joined
26 Nov 03
Moves
11918
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ih8sens
why?.. can't the rook just help out?
if you mean rook to e5 then qc8 check, followed by rxq

b
Best Loser

Traxler is Sound!

Joined
14 Nov 06
Moves
17862
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by stevetodd
if you mean rook to e5 then qc8 check, followed by rxq
oh yah i got ya.. i just looked at that quickly.

9

Joined
01 Feb 07
Moves
7819
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

hmm...that does look lost for Black. How about playing Kf8 instead of Qh5? White will get to the back rank but may need to eventually use a tempo on protecting it's own King.

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by stevetodd
if you mean rook to e5 then qc8 check, followed by rxq
um no because then re1 mate....after re5 white plays Qb3+, forcing the king on the h-hile so he takes the queen with check

s

Joined
26 Nov 03
Moves
11918
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by 93confirmed
hmm...that does look lost for Black. How about playing Kf8 instead of Qh5? White will get to the back rank but may need to eventually use a tempo on protecting it's own King.
Qf3 check then take the b pawn i reckon

o

Joined
15 Jul 06
Moves
1598
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Restless Soul
um no because then re1 mate....after re5 white plays Qb3+, forcing the king on the h-hile so he takes the queen with check
Qh5 e7 Re5 Qc8...and here you assumed Kf7 where white can play Qf8+ Ke6 e8=Q+ and on kh7 Rxq.

9

Joined
01 Feb 07
Moves
7819
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

so it looks like this is lost for Black regardless of the next move...

RS

Under ur ChessBoard!

Joined
12 Feb 07
Moves
2944
Clock
15 Mar 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by omulcusobolani
Qh5 e7 Re5 Qc8...and here you assumed Kf7 where white can play Qf8+ Ke6 e8=Q+ and on kh7 Rxq.
I know, I was refering to his RxQ before Qf8+

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.