Originally posted by FabianFnas
In certain positions, of course there are an advantage to give up the right of castling, if, and I mean if, the alternative is better. We cannot draw any conclusion out of certain games. I say statistically it is better to hold on the castling rights if nothing better turns up.
Like the question "Is a queen better than a pawn?" the usual answer is "Yes I usually answer: "It depends on the situation, but as a rule of thumb I would say ..."
Good morning my illustrious friend, how are things in Sweden? if ever you visit Norrkoping, remember me to a young lady, a flutist, she once was a true love of mine, weep weep! :'(
what can we say with regard to this idea of queen exchange? for to be sure there seems to this pathetic patzer a contradiction, for you are saying that statistically it is better for white, while on the other hand the statistics that Fat Lady have posted say quite the opposite. even his own blitz games, 90% success rate is phenomenal by anyone's standards, and 365chess.com would also seem to substantiate these statistics.
this has really got me wondering, for what can we say? if as you state that the exchange of queens leads to a disadvantage, then surely it must be bad, however, if there is no conclusive reason not to exchange queens other than its considered on the basis of statistics not to be good, then it is fear that is making us avoid the exchange, something which belongs in the realms of psychology, not on the chess board, for no chess player should ever be motivated by fear.
anyhow this really needs further exploration, for there are many variations where white actively seeks to avoid an exchange of queens, for example in the KIA against the french defense, 1.e4 e6, 2.d3 d5, 3.Nd2 is played to avoid the exchange of queens, however, there are also some instances where white actively encourages the exchange of queens, but sees no advantage, for example the exchange variation of the KID for white, although admittedly black has not given up the right to castle
1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 Bg7 4. e4 d6 5. Nf3 O-O 6. Be2 e5 7. dxe5 dxe5 8.Qxd8 Rxd8 9. Bg5
I would really like to see some games where black has been forced to give up the right to castle, perhaps be a piece sacrifice and been made to suffer. although it would seem to me that these are more likely to occur after a 1.e4 opening, rather than a 1.d4 opening when white goes all out for the f7 square, although i am perfectly willing to be proven wrong - regards robbie.