Originally posted by enrico20this is termed an ad hominen argument, in that it attacks the person rather than
The most useless advice to give new players is to tell them what you thought was useless advice (OP ahem). The OP hasn't even reached 1500, 2000 or 2300 and he thinks he knows it all.
address the points that he is making. He did not claim to 'know it all', in fact he only
cited three references from what he could recall. If you can make time to address the
points that he was actually making, rather than attack him personally, you may do
better.
Originally posted by greenpawn34no but you did, sooo where were we, , ah yes, dxc5 ...Bxc5 e4 ...Qc7 etc with Nimzo
Enrico did not mention the Colle.
declaring the position fine, for black, haha
The fact of the matter remains that every minor piece exchange is favourable for
white, exchanging dark squared bishops reduces the pressure on whites kingside and
prepares our strategy against the isolated queen pawn. Colle himself played the risky
Nh4, Kmoch suggests , 16 Bxb6 Qxb6 and Nbd4, Harding suggests, 16.Nbd4
Originally posted by robbie carrobieAd hominen argument? I had to look that up LOL! Let us see some of the OP's statements/arguments :-
this is termed an ad hominen argument, in that it attacks the person rather than
address the points that he is making. He did not claim to 'know it all', in fact he only
cited three references from what he could recall. If you can make time to address the
points that he was actually making, rather than attack him personally, you may do
better.
-I was given advice, but pretty much all of it was way over my head, therefore it was totally useless!
Really?
- The point that I was trying to make in my first post is that I believe that even good advice is useless when given to someone who isn't ready for it. At the time I was given the advice I had zippo board vision. I was giving away my pieces left and right.
The reason I started studying chess was that I was sick of not knowing what I was supposed to do.
^^^^ So on that basis the advice given to a learner driver is "useless".... a trainee starting to learn martial arts or join the army etc etc 🙄
Quite whining and learn how to play the game.
3 edits
Originally posted by enrico20you see guys, Enrico is not that prickly, so lets see the points
Ad hominen argument? I had to look that up LOL! Let us see some of the OP's statements/arguments :-
I was given advice, but pretty much all of it was way over my head, therefore it was totally useless!
Really?
- The point that I was trying to make in my first post is that I believe that even good advice is useless when given to someone rn martial arts or join the army etc etc 🙄
Quite whining and learn how to play the game.
1. Information over his head,
Yes, he was being asked to run before he could even walk, how many of us have
followed GM analysis and wondered what the heck was that all about, i have
countless times, the same phenomena happens to beginners, surely you can
empathise with him a little Enrico, after all, you were not always a 2000+ rated
player, were you? He makes a good point thought, we are told to develop our
pieces, well ok, but its not enough, we need to understand why we are developing
them to their particular posts, what it accomplishes, what is their potential, how
they fit into our over all strategy etc, that is something other than simply develop
your pieces, which to all intents and purposes is fairly vague and not that helpful,
dont you think? Try to think of what advice you would give in its stead, 'stop
whining and learn the game', well how useful is that?
Ha ha - got ya!
You said, posting this position;
The fact of the matter remains that every minor piece exchange is
favourable for white.
I cannot see a White plus after the minor piece exchange Bxe4 dxe4.
I see the c6 Knight going to e5 and d3 (please pin it with Bf4 when it's on e5).
What game was this anyway? I'm getting flash backs.
1 edit
Originally posted by greenpawn34Lol, ok, almost every white minor piece exchange, it was a Colle v Kashdan 1931
Ha ha - got ya!
You said, posting this position;
[fen]r3r1k1/ppq2ppp/1bn3b1/3p4/4n3/1NPBBN2/PPQ2PPP/4RRK1 w - - 0 1[/fen]
The fact of the matter remains that every minor piece exchange is
favourable for white.
I cannot see a White plus after the minor piece exchange Bxe4 dxe4.
[fen]r3r1k1/ppq2ppp/1bn3b1/8/4p3/1NP1BN2/PPQ2PPP/4RRK1 w - - ...[text shortened]... lease pin it with Bf4 when it's on e5).
What game was this anyway? I'm getting flash backs.
0-1, which Colle lost by playing a very risky manoeuvre and Kashdan offers a
sacrifice, check it out.
Originally posted by tortenwhen i was first introduced to chess, my teacher taught me to move a rook pawn to the
In the beginning the first bit of advice I got was to bring out the queen early.
But it doesn't really count as useless because I won many games with scholar's mate.
So yeah...
fourth rank then the fifth and then bring my rook out to form an impenetrable wall
along the forth rank. I still think it has merit.
1 edit
Originally posted by enrico20Just goes to show that people think that what's good advice for 1800's is good advice for 800's. That's the point I was trying to make with this thread.
The most useless advice to give new players is to tell them what you thought was useless advice (OP ahem). The OP hasn't even reached 1500, 2000 or 2300 and he thinks he knows it all.
You've got to deal with people where they are. Any good educator knows this for a fact.
