Could this be the earliest RHP clanger ? At the time this would have been a top of the table clash... black was cruising.. them on #38 loses his queen and it's rook versus 4 pawns.. could white have drawn from there ? White missed mate on #39 too.. he never recovered and left the site a few months later.
[Event "Open invite"]
[Site "http://www.redhotpawn.com"]
[Date "2001.04.21"]
[EndDate "2001.05.02"]
[Round "?"]
[White "carl r"]
[Black "Rhymester"]
[WhiteRating "1221"]
[BlackRating "1445"]
[WhiteElo "1221"]
[BlackElo "1445"]
[Result "0-1"]
[GameId "3694"]
1. e4 e5 2. Bf1c4 Ng8f6 3. Qd1f3 Nb8c6 4. c3 Bf8c5 5. Ng1h3 O-O 6. Nh3g5 d6 7. b4 Bc5b6 8. b5 Nc6a5 9. Nb1a3 Bc8g4 10. Qf3g3 Qd8d7 11. Qg3h4 h6 12. Ng5f3 Nf6xe4 13. d4 h5 14. dxe5 Ra8e8 15. h3 Bg4xf3 16. gxf3 Bb6xf2 17. Qh4xf2 Ne4xf2 18. Ke1xf2 Re8xe5 19. Bc1f4 Re5f5 20. Bf4e3 Rf8e8 21. Rh1g1 Rf5xf3 22. Kf2xf3 Qd7xh3 23. Rg1g3 Re8xe3 24. Kf3xe3 Qh3xg3 25. Ke3d2 d5 26. Bc4d3 Na5c4 27. Bd3xc4 dxc4 28. Na3xc4 Qg3g5 29. Nc4e3 h4 30. Kd2e2 h3 31. Ra1h1 Qg5xb5 32. c4 Qb5b2 33. Ke2f3 a5 34. Rh1xh3 Qb2xa2 35. Ne3f5 Qa2xc4 36. Nf5e7 Kg8f8 37. Ne7f5 Qc4c3 38. Kf3g4 g6 39. Rh3xc3 gxf5 40. Kg4xf5 c6 41. Kf5f6 Kf8e8 42. Rc3e3 Ke8d8 43. Kf6xf7 a4 44. Re3a3 b5 45. Kf7e6 Kd8c7 46. Ra3d3 Kc7b6 47. Ke6d6 c5 48. Kd6d5 c4 49. Rd3d4 Kb6a5 50. Kd5c5 a3 51. Rd4d8 Ka5a4 52. Rd8a8 Ka4b3 53. Kc5xb5 c3 54. Ra8a6 c2 55. Ra6c6 Kb3b2 56. Kb5a4 a2 57. Rc6xc2 Kb2xc2 58. Ka4b5 a1=Q 59. Kb5c5 Kc2d3 60. Kc5c6 Qa1d4 61. Kc6c7 Qd4d5 0-1