Go back
who had the advantage before I screwed it up?

who had the advantage before I screwed it up?

Only Chess

M

Joined
31 Jan 07
Moves
7017
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

I've lost the last 8 games in a row. Maybe I'm not eating right.

I was wondering if anyone could tell me who had the advantage here before I screwed it up. Are two rooks generally better in an end game than a Queen?

Game 3433172

DD
Stealer of Souls

Waiting for You

Joined
16 Feb 07
Moves
119052
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by MKinsch
I've lost the last 8 games in a row. Maybe I'm not eating right.

I was wondering if anyone could tell me who had the advantage here before I screwed it up. Are two rooks generally better in an end game than a Queen?

Game 3433172
You did. 😞

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by MKinsch
I've lost the last 8 games in a row. Maybe I'm not eating right.

I was wondering if anyone could tell me who had the advantage here before I screwed it up. Are two rooks generally better in an end game than a Queen?

Game 3433172
I played it out, I think you probably should have won that - that absolute pin HAS to be avoided.

MR

Joined
19 Jun 06
Moves
847
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Even if Black had avoided the absolute pin on move 38, I'm not sure that Black had a win. White's double rook attack on the king might have been able to force a draw. Black's only hope to avoid the draw would be to retreat the king to the h5 square, but in that case, I'd be afraid that the two rooks might be able to mate Black.

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mad Rook
Even if Black had avoided the absolute pin on move 38, I'm not sure that Black had a win. White's double rook attack on the king might have been able to force a draw. Black's only hope to avoid the draw would be to retreat the king to the h5 square, but in that case, I'd be afraid that the two rooks might be able to mate Black.
That's the way my line played out, but I was able to check the king and push a pawn so the king had an escape square. It was just me playing out moves quickly though, so it's far from the verdict.

MR

Joined
19 Jun 06
Moves
847
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by cmsMaster
That's the way my line played out, but I was able to check the king and push a pawn so the king had an escape square. It was just me playing out moves quickly though, so it's far from the verdict.
Yeah, I just glanced at it quickly myself and didn't look at any moves before move 38. I think if Black had any real winnning chances, it had to be before move 38.

M

Joined
31 Jan 07
Moves
7017
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mad Rook
Yeah, I just glanced at it quickly myself and didn't look at any moves before move 38. I think if Black had any real winnning chances, it had to be before move 38.
Yeah I definitely lost all hope after move 38. I didn't factor in that it would take a move to kill his rook after he took my Queen. I was hoping to simplify and rely on my nifty pawn structure. I'm cursed with an extremely distractable brain. Thanks for the replies.

B

Joined
03 Jan 07
Moves
6396
Clock
20 Apr 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

There was nothing wrong with your move 38. But you should have played 39. ... g3+!!, with a winning position.

MR

Joined
19 Jun 06
Moves
847
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by BlueViking
There was nothing wrong with your move 38. But you should have played 39. ... g3+!!, with a winning position.
Wow, I think you're right... How did I miss that one? I guess that's why I'm just a patzer, lol. (I should have checked it with Fritz)

M

Earth

Joined
04 Aug 06
Moves
28868
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by MKinsch
I've lost the last 8 games in a row. Maybe I'm not eating right.

I was wondering if anyone could tell me who had the advantage here before I screwed it up. Are two rooks generally better in an end game than a Queen?

Game 3433172
With reference to your question 'are 2 rooks better than a queen' this very much depends on the specifics of the position.
Often a queen is more than a match for 2 rooks due to her lighthouse effect when occupying central squares, but against connect rooks (particularly on the 7th rank) she can be totally outclassed.
A good guideline is that a queen becomes more powerful against the rook pair the more pieces she has in support (in a materially balanced game). King position plays a key role.

M

Joined
31 Jan 07
Moves
7017
Clock
20 Apr 07
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mad Rook
Wow, I think you're right... How did I miss that one? I guess that's why I'm just a patzer, lol. (I should have checked it with Fritz)
Oh dang! That makes me sad. I looked at that move for a while but all I could see was my threatening pawns all getting slaughtered. I didn't realize that when he moved his king away I could have taken his rook. Well at least I got to a point where a win was in the general vicinity.

C

EDMONTON ALBERTA

Joined
30 Sep 05
Moves
10841
Clock
20 Apr 07
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

hmmm.... 39...g3+ hxg3 then what? h3? then Rxe4 fxe4?

Nevermind, I see it now! nice!

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.