19 Oct '04 15:58>
Originally posted by AThousandYoungThe idea is that (once you remove common knowledge) when the prophet proclaims to everyone that adultery has been committed then common knowledge results from perfect rationality. That is every woman knows that every woman knows that adultery has been committed.
If everyone has slept with everyone, then every woman knew adultery had been committed before the prophet came, because they committed it!
With this and a years time every wife is simultaneously able to eliminate the possibility that only her husband is faithful, leaving only that every husband is cheating. Tragedy and mayhem insue . . .