Go back
Astronomy?s

Astronomy?s

Posers and Puzzles

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by cheshirecatstevens
The apparent expansion rate a nebula is 0.43 arcsec per year. The apparent size of the nebula is about 4 by 5.7 arcmin. If the expansion rate remains constant, calculate how long it will be until the long axis of the nebula has the same apparent size as the full moon (0.50 degree or 1800 arcsec).
Perhaps i am mistaken but this is one of those "looks hard but actually quite easy" problems.

60 arcsec = 1 arc min

We want long axis of apparent size of nebula to span 1800 arcsec, it currently spans 5.7*60 = 342 arcsec

Therefore apparent size of nebula needs to grow 1800 - 342 = 1458 arcsec

Apparent size grows at 0.43 arcsec/year

Therefore it will take 1458/0.43 = 3390.7 years give or take a few weeks.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
Maybe the star is in front. Ever thought of THAT, GENIUS?!?!?!??!

😠
Thank you for the compliment, but I am not really a genius. 🙄

The moon is about 384 000 kilometres from earth. The nearest star, our sun, is about 150 000 000 kilometres from us. If any star would lie in front of the moon we would be burnt to ashes in a microsecond.

Oh, you made a joke? See? I'm not a genius after all! 😉

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FabianFnas
Thank you for the compliment, but I am not really a genius. 🙄

The moon is about 384 000 kilometres from earth. The nearest star, our sun, is about 150 000 000 kilometres from us. If any star would lie in front of the moon we would be burnt to ashes in a microsecond.

Oh, you made a joke? See? I'm not a genius after all! 😉
But you said your IQ was 190...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sonhouse
But you said your IQ was 190...
Never said this?
You must mistake me for another...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FabianFnas
Never said this?
You must mistake me for another...
Don't tell me what to do 😠

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sonhouse
But you said your IQ was 190...

Originally posted by FabianFnas
Never said this?
You must mistake me for another...


Originally posted by PBE6
Don't tell me what to do 😠
I've never told you to do anything!

Interesting...

PBE6 and sonhouse must be the same person...?
I don't get it?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Marsan
Perhaps i am mistaken but this is one of those "looks hard but actually quite easy" problems.

60 arcsec = 1 arc min

We want long axis of apparent size of nebula to span 1800 arcsec, it currently spans 5.7*60 = 342 arcsec

Therefore apparent size of nebula needs to grow 1800 - 342 = 1458 arcsec

Apparent size grows at 0.43 arcsec/year

Therefore it will take 1458/0.43 = 3390.7 years give or take a few weeks.
haha. nobody responds to either of the answers we gave.....classic.