Posers and Puzzles

Posers and Puzzles

  1. Standard membertalzamir
    Art, not a Toil
    60.13N / 25.01E
    Joined
    19 Sep '11
    Moves
    46187
    12 May '12 08:53
    Five guys have had a party in the desert, and take a taxi to get home. They agree that each of the four pays a share of the cab fare that reflects the costs that are caused by taking him home, as is, after all, fair. Calling the cab in the first place costs $8, and there is an extra $1 per mile.

    From the party place at (0,0) the taxi drives
    * drop Andrew off at (3,4)
    * drop Bob off at (6,0)
    * drop Chuck off at (9,0)
    * drop Dan off at (9,4)

    Ed doesn't need to get into the taxi at all, as this time the party was at Ed's home.

    The total cost is $8 + $5 + $5 + $3 + $4 = $25.

    How much should everyone pay for the cab fair?
  2. ALG
    Joined
    16 Dec '07
    Moves
    6190
    13 May '12 14:46
    You've posted this one a while ago, with islands and a ship instead of a desert and a cab. 🙂
  3. Standard membertalzamir
    Art, not a Toil
    60.13N / 25.01E
    Joined
    19 Sep '11
    Moves
    46187
    19 May '12 19:15
    oops! ^^ Sorry about that. A nice problem anyhow. I thought of it again when thinking of the Roman inheritance, as they both look simple enough on top but it is hard to justify one answer to be the only correct one.
  4. SubscriberPianoman1
    Nil desperandum
    Seedy piano bar
    Joined
    09 May '08
    Moves
    195178
    20 May '12 06:49
    Originally posted by talzamir
    Five guys have had a party in the desert, and take a taxi to get home. They agree that each of the four pays a share of the cab fare that reflects the costs that are caused by taking him home, as is, after all, fair. Calling the cab in the first place costs $8, and there is an extra $1 per mile.

    From the party place at (0,0) the taxi drives
    * drop Andre ...[text shortened]... total cost is $8 + $5 + $5 + $3 + $4 = $25.

    How much should everyone pay for the cab fair?
    This is similar to the restaurant conundrum:

    Three customers go to a restaurant and have a meal. The bill comes to £25. They each a give a £10 note to the waiter. He can't work out how much change to give back to each customer, so he keeps £2 tip and gives £1 back to each customer.
    So the customers have paid £9 each, (£27), the waiter has £2. Where is the missing £1?
  5. ALG
    Joined
    16 Dec '07
    Moves
    6190
    20 May '12 13:131 edit
    Originally posted by talzamir
    oops! ^^ Sorry about that. A nice problem anyhow. I thought of it again when thinking of the Roman inheritance, as they both look simple enough on top but it is hard to justify one answer to be the only correct one.
    That's true. I would give A, B, C, and D a weight equal to the total costs minus the costs they would've had without that person. So for A it would be $25 - ($8 + $6 + $3 + $4) = $25 - $21 = 4
  6. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16162
    21 May '12 21:30
    Originally posted by Pianoman1
    This is similar to the restaurant conundrum:

    Three customers go to a restaurant and have a meal. The bill comes to £25. They each a give a £10 note to the waiter. He can't work out how much change to give back to each customer, so he keeps £2 tip and gives £1 back to each customer.
    So the customers have paid £9 each, (£27), the waiter has £2. Where is the missing £1?
    Surprisingly hard to see how people think about this the wrong way.

    The customers each paid $9 x 3 = $27: true
    The waiter has $2: true
    The waiter's $2 is separate from the $27 the customers paid: false

    $27 (paid by the customers) - $2 (kept by the waiter) = $25 (the bill)
  7. Standard memberwolfgang59
    Mr. Wolf
    at home
    Joined
    09 Jun '07
    Moves
    46016
    22 May '12 09:31
    Originally posted by forkedknight
    Surprisingly hard to see how people think about this the wrong way.

    The customers each paid $9 x 3 = $27: true
    The waiter has $2: true
    The waiter's $2 is separate from the $27 the customers paid: false

    $27 (paid by the customers) - $2 (kept by the waiter) = $25 (the bill)
    But what happened to the $30 they paid?
  8. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16162
    22 May '12 18:41
    Originally posted by wolfgang59
    But what happened to the $30 they paid?
    Serious question? The other $3 was returned in change.

    $30 - $3 (change) - $2 (waiter) = $25 (bill)
  9. Joined
    26 Apr '03
    Moves
    26504
    26 May '12 23:21
    Originally posted by Pianoman1
    This is similar to the restaurant conundrum:

    Three customers go to a restaurant and have a meal. The bill comes to £25. They each a give a £10 note to the waiter. He can't work out how much change to give back to each customer, so he keeps £2 tip and gives £1 back to each customer.
    So the customers have paid £9 each, (£27), the waiter has £2. Where is the missing £1?
    The last bit:
    So the customers have paid £9 each, (£27), the waiter has £2. Where is the missing £1?
    9*3 + 2 =....
    i.e. it is wrongly adding what the customers have paid in total to what they paid the waiter

    Should read:
    So the customers have paid £9 each, (£27), the waiter has £2 and the restaurant has its £25
    9*3 - 2 = 25

    or
    So the customers paid £10 each, (£30), the waiter has £2, the customers got back £3 and the restaurant has its £25
    10 - 2 - 3 = 25
Back to Top