Go back
Seasons without axial tilt?

Seasons without axial tilt?

Posers and Puzzles

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26755
Clock
04 Mar 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Seasons are caused by the tilt of the Earth's axis of rotation. Now, imagine a planet which has an axis of rotation exactly perpendicular to the plane of it's orbit, yet still has seasons...how?

The planet's orbit is not circular. It's elliptical. Therefore the planet is sometimes closer to it's sun, and sometimes farther, and the distance is significant enough to change the average temperature.

As a result the equator experiences seasons, and there are two summers and two winters per revolution around the sun.

Assuming the planet is otherwise like Earth, and the sun is like our Sun...

Describe the ellipse necessary to create seasons comparable in average temperature to the ones we experience on Earth in the temperate zones.

😕

l
Man of Steel

rushing to and fro

Joined
13 Aug 05
Moves
5930
Clock
04 Mar 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
The planet's orbit is not circular. It's elliptical. Therefore the planet is sometimes closer to it's sun, and sometimes farther, and the distance is significant enough to change the average temperature.

As a result the equator experiences seasons, and there are two summers and two winters per revolution around the sun.
Two summer and two winters per revolution? Why?

A

Joined
02 Mar 06
Moves
17881
Clock
04 Mar 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by leisurelysloth
Two summer and two winters per revolution? Why?
only explanation i can think of is the sun is smack dab in the middle of the two focii? and so at the edges of the minor axis of the ellipse earth is experiencing summer, and at the ends of the major axis earth experiences winter? but i don't know the physics behind why earth would be traveling around a relatively "central" point in an elliptical orbit... seems counter-intuitive to me.

S

Dublin

Joined
07 Feb 05
Moves
8227
Clock
04 Mar 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Aetherael
only explanation i can think of is the sun is smack dab in the middle of the two focii? and so at the edges of the minor axis of the ellipse earth is experiencing summer, and at the ends of the major axis earth experiences winter? but i don't know the physics behind why earth would be traveling around a relatively "central" point in an elliptical orbit... seems counter-intuitive to me.
The sun is always at one of the foci, isn't it?

A

Joined
02 Mar 06
Moves
17881
Clock
04 Mar 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Schumi
The sun is always at one of the foci, isn't it?
that's the way it should work, but then annually there would be a summer a winter, and two similar seasons resembling fall and spring... but the OP said there were supposed to be two winters and two summers so i was trying to construct a way in which this was possible.

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26755
Clock
04 Mar 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Schumi
The sun is always at one of the foci, isn't it?
I got this from some other forum, and the same thing was pointed out. OK. Forget the two summers and winters then.

D

Joined
12 Sep 07
Moves
2668
Clock
22 Mar 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

How about Terry Pratchett's Discworld?

wolfgang59
Quiz Master

RHP Arms

Joined
09 Jun 07
Moves
48794
Clock
23 Mar 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

This is still a valid question. How eccentric would an orbit have to be to emulate the Earths tilt?

Without googling I seem to remember that we get 5% extra energy at perigee which occurs in early January. How that affects climate/seasons I have no idea.

Is the Earth as a whole warmer in JaN?

Cooler in July?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.