for the holidays

in the spirit of joy, love and good cheer
let's hope robbie gets a second chance
what say you Russ?

Originally posted by @lemondrop
in the spirit of joy, love and good cheer
let's hope robbie gets a second chance
what say you Russ?

What for?

Originally posted by @lemondrop
in the spirit of joy, love and good cheer
let's hope robbie gets a second chance
what say you Russ?

Second chance?

More like 200 before the inevitable.

But I actually agree with you he should be allowed back but calling the owner names and not having a sub did not help him.

The same thing mctayto is now doing to me Russ has a choice unban Robbie or ban mctayto easy choice

Originally posted by @divegeester
What for?

why not?

Originally posted by @lemondrop
in the spirit of joy, love and good cheer
let's hope robbie gets a second chance
what say you Russ?

Maiden Gertrude,

Do you seriously think he learned his lesson? What makes you think he even wants to come back after the fool he made of himself on this site? I had private conversations telling him he was going down the wrong road and it would catch up with him eventually which it did. Do you know what he may have said to Russ? It must have been something pretty bad for Russ to ban him as Russ has a pretty thick skin.

My vote would be NO, not at this time.

-VR

Originally posted by @lemondrop
why not?

The onus is on you to make a case, so far not too impressive.

Originally posted by @divegeester
The onus is on you to make a case, so far not too impressive.

I'll take my case to Russ
not you

Originally posted by @lemondrop
I'll take my case to Russ
not you

I would say Russ already made his decision. How do you plan on changing his mind?

-VR

Originally posted by @lemondrop
I'll take my case to Russ
not you

Actually you brought your case here.
With this thread.
And then put the onus on others to justify not letting Robbie back.

We've seen that tactic before.
(Please see challenge dumping thread).

Originally posted by @very-rusty
I would say Russ already made his decision. How do you plan on changing his mind?

-VR

with reason
and if that doesn't work
I'll beg

Originally posted by @lemondrop
with reason
and if that doesn't work
I'll beg

What reason?

He did make his bed, did he not?

-VR

Originally posted by @mghrn55
Actually you brought your case here.
With this thread.
And then put the onus on others to justify not letting Robbie back.

We've seen that tactic before.
(Please see challenge dumping thread).

I did bring my case here
I simply asked that he be forgiven
what else is there to say?
you and others want to argue why he shouldn't be allowed back
and then turn it around on me

Originally posted by @lemondrop
I did bring my case here
I simply asked that he be forgiven
what else is there to say?
you and others want to argue why he shouldn't be allowed back
and then turn it around on me

You haven't given you case.

What are your reasons you believe he should be allowed back?

That is what else there is to say!

-VR

Originally posted by @very-rusty
You haven't given you case.

What are your reasons you believe he should be allowed back?

That is what else there is to say!

-VR

I don't even know why he was banned
he was an interesting fellow
he brought a point of view
like it or not
but hardliners like you will never show any mercy

Originally posted by @lemondrop
I don't even know why he was banned
he was an interesting fellow
he brought a point of view
like it or not
but hardliners like you will never show any mercy

I think Carrobie should be unbanned.

Then dragged into this forum in chains, given 50 lashes with a cat-o-nine-tails, then banned permanently immediately after.

This should be a yearly practice enacted to draw in the crowds.

Maybe we can change the punishment each year. Next year we'll have a stoning !!!