for the holidays

Originally posted by @radioactive69
I think Carrobie should be unbanned.

Then dragged into this forum in chains, given 50 lashes with a cat-o-nine-tails, then banned permanently immediately after.

This should be a yearly practice enacted to draw in the crowds.

Maybe we can change the punishment each year. Next year we'll have a stoning !!!

Maybe we'll even let him start a clan. Or four.
NOT !!

Originally posted by @lemondrop
I did bring my case here
I simply asked that he be forgiven
what else is there to say?
you and others want to argue why he shouldn't be allowed back
and then turn it around on me

But there’s no indication at all that he’s penitent. He’s not sorry for what he’s done and there’s no firm intention to behave properly in the future.

Those things have to happen first. And convincingly.

Originally posted by @startreader
But there’s no indication at all that he’s penitent. He’s not sorry for what he’s done and there’s no firm intention to behave properly in the future.

Those things have to happen first. And convincingly.

He also needs to admit that he systematically manipulated (cheated) the clan system and name his fellow conspirators (most of whom we already know).

That's just for starters. There will be many more penances he needs to perform before he would be allowed back on the site.

Russ knew what he was doing when he banned carrobie. The clan forum had slipped into an almighty slanging match and was getting out of control so he nipped in the bud the worst perpetrator and presto..........peace and quiet ever since. Smart man the old Russ.

robbie wasn't banned for anything he did
he was banned apparently for something he said
so I'm just asking Russ to lift the ban
that's all

Originally posted by @lemondrop
robbie wasn't banned for anything he did
he was banned apparently for something he said
so I'm just asking Russ to lift the ban
that's all

Get at least 30 or 40 players to pm Russ on Robbies behalf

Should be easy just get all those involved in the collision fiasco from last year.

Originally posted by @lemondrop
I don't even know why he was banned
he was an interesting fellow
he brought a point of view
like it or not
but hardliners like you will never show any mercy

Perhaps your first step should be to find out WHY he was banned.

Russ doesn't ban anyone unless he has a very good reason(s), with your friend Robbie he could make a long list of reasons of why, although he really doesn't have to give anyone a reason as to why.

Interesting? That is quite questionable due to the scheme he tried to win first place in the Clan Championships. He was involved in Collusion with other teams to gain an advantage which was pointed out and facts shown as you well know.

Point of view? If you collude with other teams you can win? I believe that is called Cheating not a point of view, like it or not.

Call me a hardliner if you like, but i have pointed out FACTS to you, something Robbie didn't like or would ignore as you are doing now.

-VR

Originally posted by @lemondrop
robbie wasn't banned for anything he did
he was banned apparently for something he said
so I'm just asking Russ to lift the ban
that's all

Saying is “doing” when it is publically attacking the integrity of the site and the owner. He was stupid and got banned for it. I disagreed with Russ on something recently but sent my POV privately.

Having said that I remember another member being banned and being reinstated by Russ after appeal. However that was for general repeated misbehaviour not for slagging off Russ.

If Carrobie wants back I imagine his first step would be to send Russ an apology and promise not to reoffend.

Originally posted by @divegeester
Saying is “doing” when it is publically attacking the integrity of the site and the owner. He was stupid and got banned for it. I disagreed with Russ on something recently but sent my POV privately.

Having said that I remember another member being banned and being reinstated by Russ after appeal. However that was for general repeated misbehaviour no ...[text shortened]... ants back I imagine his first step would be to send Russ an apology and promise not to reoffend.

can a person with a site ban even contact Russ?

Originally posted by @lemondrop
can a person with a site ban even contact Russ?

Yes a player can send feedback even if they are banned.
But Robbie does not want to come back.
End of story

Originally posted by @lemondrop
in the spirit of joy, love and good cheer
let's hope robbie gets a second chance
what say you Russ?

A second chance to do what?

Originally posted by @lemondrop
in the spirit of joy, love and good cheer
let's hope robbie gets a second chance
what say you Russ?

Whats the difference between saying that and saying, "I got rid of my cancer, I hope I can get it back again".....whats up with that Spooge?