1. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344791
    15 Nov '17 13:22
    To stop the endless whining I finally came up with a system.
    1) ban any player who moans about the current system.
    2) see point 1 if still in doubt
    That was easy

    Anyone agree/disagree
  2. Joined
    16 Jan '07
    Moves
    326037
    15 Nov '17 14:25
    Originally posted by @roma45
    To stop the endless whining I finally came up with a system.
    1) ban any player who moans about the current system.
    2) see point 1 if still in doubt
    That was easy

    Anyone agree/disagree
    It has the simplicity of genius about it, Roma.
  3. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295635
    15 Nov '17 14:54
    Originally posted by @roma45
    To stop the endless whining I finally came up with a system.
    1) ban any player who moans about the current system.
    2) see point 1 if still in doubt
    That was easy

    Anyone agree/disagree
    So you not only do not want to see what is plainly not a fair system
    You want to run a dictatorship where the only person who is right is you
  4. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344791
    15 Nov '17 15:25
    Originally posted by @padger
    So you not only do not want to see what is plainly not a fair system
    You want to run a dictatorship where the only person who is right is you
    Nothing wrong with a dictatorship as long as I am in charge.

    You really don't get sarcasm
  5. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295635
    16 Nov '17 06:59
    I see the Clan scoring system like a football match
    The Challenge = the Match
    Games Won = Goals for
    Games Lost =Goals against
    So the Match won should equal 3 points
    Match drawn 1 point each
    Match lost no points
    Because Clan Matches ( Challenges ) are not made up of equal numbers of games
    I would address this by taking goals for ( Games won ) - goals against ( Games lost )
    This would then be multiplied by the win

    In a 5 man challenge

    Result 5 games won each = Clan A 1 pt Clan B 1 pt

    Clan a 6 games won 4 games lost = clan A 6 pts clan B 0

    Clan a 7 games won 3 games lost = clan A 12 pts clan B 0

    Clan a 8 games won 2 games lost = clan A 18 pts clan B 0

    Clan a 9 games won 1 games lost = clan A 24 pts clan B 0

    Clan a 10 games won 0 games lost = clan A 30 pts clan B 0

    This system would encourage bigger clans taking on bigger challenges
    Unlike the present system which is unfair and encourages smaller clans with 1 to 1 challenges
  6. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344791
    16 Nov '17 09:32
    Originally posted by @padger
    I see the Clan scoring system like a football match
    The Challenge = the Match
    Games Won = Goals for
    Games Lost =Goals against
    So the Match won should equal 3 points
    Match drawn 1 point each
    Match lost no points
    Because Clan Matches ( Challenges ) are not made up of equal numbers of games
    I would address this by taking goals for ( Games won ) - goal ...[text shortened]...
    Unlike the present system which is unfair and encourages smaller clans with 1 to 1 challenges
    The clan you run has ten players
    All your waiting challenges are 1 v 1

    Resent results are one or two player challenges. One a five player match. Which is rather than Nessie being spotted.

    The 200 rating buffer has destroyed large challenges forever.

    In football it's three points for a win. It used to be two going by the old scoring system some teams would have won the league or being relegated.
    But they knew the rules when they played the games.
    Same here in the clan system. Leaders know what is at stake before playing.

    The vast majority of clan leader just accept a challenge without wasting time researching the history of players. I do that because I have more important things to do.

    Lemon biggest sandbagger on here gets hundreds of games.
    Why? Because few read this forum and fewer really care.
    Try site ideas with any ideas or pm Russ. But don't hold your breathe to get what you want.it took 18 months to sort out obvious cheating.

    Do you honestly think you can get enough support to make the system more complicated.

    Never going to happen.

    Next year will be different a few clans will challenge Metallica fairly
  7. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295635
    16 Nov '17 10:12
    Originally posted by @roma45
    The clan you run has ten players
    All your waiting challenges are 1 v 1

    Resent results are one or two player challenges. One a five player match. Which is rather than Nessie being spotted.

    The 200 rating buffer has destroyed large challenges forever.

    In football it's three points for a win. It used to be two going by the old scoring system some team ...[text shortened]... ever going to happen.

    Next year will be different a few clans will challenge Metallica fairly
    So you looked it over and cannot find anything wrong with it
    So you just criticise it
    Typical
  8. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344791
    16 Nov '17 12:10
    Originally posted by @padger
    So you looked it over and cannot find anything wrong with it
    So you just criticise it
    Typical
    Typical?.
    I showed you not for the first time. Large clan challenges can't happen any more your own clan plays 1v1 a lot of the time.
    As for your latest idea try putting it in site ideas. See if there is support.
    Or will you do the TYPICAL and just moan as usual?
  9. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295635
    16 Nov '17 12:371 edit
    Originally posted by @roma45
    Typical?.
    I showed you not for the first time. Large clan challenges can't happen any more your own clan plays 1v1 a lot of the time.
    As for your latest idea try putting it in site ideas. See if there is support.
    Or will you do the TYPICAL and just moan as usual?
    Temper Temper
    I thought you had called this thread " New Clan Points System "
  10. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344791
    16 Nov '17 13:43
    Originally posted by @padger
    Temper Temper
    I thought you had called this thread " New Clan Points System "
    Next time I make a joke I will add (only joking)

    The point is
    Your ideas are stupid and would not help
    You are just wanting a complicated gross points system we already had that.
    Your latest idea. I use the word idea lightly makes no sense
    Try it out at site ideas. If you get enough support the system will change.
    More chance if planet X hitting earth on the 19th November though.
  11. Here
    Joined
    31 May '06
    Moves
    295635
    16 Nov '17 14:59
    Originally posted by @roma45
    Next time I make a joke I will add (only joking)

    The point is
    Your ideas are stupid and would not help
    You are just wanting a complicated gross points system we already had that.
    Your latest idea. I use the word idea lightly makes no sense
    Try it out at site ideas. If you get enough support the system will change.
    More chance if planet X hitting earth on the 19th November though.
    The system that makes no sense is the one we have now
    If you applied this system to the Scottish Premier league St Johnston would be minus 23 by now
  12. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344791
    16 Nov '17 16:04
    Originally posted by @padger
    The system that makes no sense is the one we have now
    If you applied this system to the Scottish Premier league St Johnston would be minus 23 by now
    If that's what was said at the START of the season then there would be no problem.
    You are either at the wind up or more alarmingly don't understand.

    It does not matter which way points are awarded. A team has to win more to be champions.
    Net points us much fairer than the gross system we used to have.and one you seem to want to return to
    That unfairly helps not only large clans but clans who play more games.
    The net system was introduced to make it quality v quantity

    Honestly this is the last time I will attempt to explain it too you.
    .if you have a idea try site ideas.

    See what happens
    .
  13. Joined
    30 Sep '11
    Moves
    42144
    20 Dec '17 22:51
    Originally posted by @roma45
    To stop the endless whining I finally came up with a system.
    1) ban any player who moans about the current system.
    2) see point 1 if still in doubt
    That was easy

    Anyone agree/disagree
    FRISP Knob...
  14. Subscriberroma45
    st johnstone
    Joined
    14 Nov '09
    Moves
    344791
    21 Dec '17 08:39
    Originally posted by @sirdubalot
    FRISP Knob...
    And a merry Christmas to you as well.
    Maybe get santa to buy you a sub?

    Or a you really wanting a frisk knob?
    Not sure what that is. But each to their own sexual fantasys

    Enjoy.
  15. Joined
    30 Sep '11
    Moves
    42144
    21 Dec '17 20:47
    Originally posted by @roma45
    And a merry Christmas to you as well.
    Maybe get santa to buy you a sub?

    Or a you really wanting a frisk knob?
    Not sure what that is. But each to their own sexual fantasys

    Enjoy.
    It’s FRISP not frisk
Back to Top