Go back
Can New orleans survive?

Can New orleans survive?

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Hurricane and storm season has already begun, with a few minor storms that havn't really touched the US. However, the next 2 months will undoubtedly bring about a few rather large hurricanes that will threaten areas of the United States.

I bring this up because i just read this article:

http://www.cnn.com/2006/US/08/25/levee.report/index.html

All they are doing is just talking about how to rebuild and figuring out what went wrong. They are saying "there is no quick fix." What if.....just what if, they get hit again this year? They should be very, very worried, and I hear no talk of worry about the coming season. I would not want to be anywhere near new orleans for the next 2 months. Can they survive if any size hurricane hits them? Do you feel they are doing all they can do to fix the situation?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by PocketKings
Hurricane and storm season has already begun, with a few minor storms that havn't really touched the US. However, the next 2 months will undoubtedly bring about a few rather large hurricanes that will threaten areas of the United States.

I bring this up because i just read this article:

http://www.cnn.com/2006/US/08/25/levee.report/index.html

A ...[text shortened]... ny size hurricane hits them? Do you feel they are doing all they can do to fix the situation?
They need to ask the Dutch for advise on building storm-proof dykes because obviously the Army Corps of Engineers has no clue. Have they done so?....naw, just waiting for Katrina II...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by PocketKings
Hurricane and storm season has already begun, with a few minor storms that havn't really touched the US. However, the next 2 months will undoubtedly bring about a few rather large hurricanes that will threaten areas of the United States.

I bring this up because i just read this article:

http://www.cnn.com/2006/US/08/25/levee.report/index.html

A ...[text shortened]... ny size hurricane hits them? Do you feel they are doing all they can do to fix the situation?
Of course they'll survive. No one, not even nature, has ever managed to slow up gambling, drinking, drugs, prostitution and jazz for long. Though perhaps people should not insist on living in a depression between a large river, large lake and large gulf.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Delmer
Of course they'll survive. No one, not even nature, has ever managed to slow up gambling, drinking, drugs, prostitution and jazz for long. Though perhaps people should not insist on living in a depression between a large river, large lake and large gulf.
Good point...but give up trolling for hookers? 😞 😉

Vote Up
Vote Down

Should N.O. be abandonned? Or should man continue to attempt to defy nature?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HumeA
Should N.O. be abandonned? Or should man continue to attempt to defy nature?
No, they should learn from the Dutch. I'm simply amazed that the moronic mayor of N.O. hasn't consulted with Dutch engineers. Should Holland be abandoned simply because their dykes are holding back the North Sea successfully and have been for years?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HumeA
Should N.O. be abandonned? Or should man continue to attempt to defy nature?
Should be abandonned and it mostly is already..

Pimps, cheep whores, gang-bangers, grifters and failed politicans are all that remain.

Back off about 50 miles, wait 50 yrs and lets go fishin'.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by jammer
Should be abandonned and it mostly is already..

Pimps, cheep whores, gang-bangers, grifters and failed politicans are all that remain.

Back off about 50 miles, wait 50 yrs and lets go fishin'.
And rename the "Super Dome" the "Gator Dome"...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by chancremechanic
No, they should learn from the Dutch. I'm simply amazed that the moronic mayor of N.O. hasn't consulted with Dutch engineers. Should Holland be abandoned simply because their dykes are holding back the North Sea successfully and have been for years?
Ray Nagan is amazing. I've never seen anyone play the victim hand like him. When a reporter asked him about all the abandoned cars still in New Orleans, he basically said "Come on, give me a break. They have a big concrete hole in NYC (World Trade Center) that they haven't fixed in 5 years.

Vote Up
Vote Down

All they are doing is just talking about how to rebuild and figuring out what went wrong. ?[/b]
What went wrong is that they build their city 50 feet under sea level so when the sea comes in unless their bulidings can float "their gonna have a bad time."

PLus that comment about rolling for hooker was funny

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by chancremechanic
They need to ask the Dutch for advise on building storm-proof dykes because obviously the Army Corps of Engineers has no clue. Have they done so?....naw, just waiting for Katrina II...
Money has been the issue not incompetance. Money has a way of 'disappearing' in Louisianna. For years the Corps and others had been requesting funding to overhaul the levees... sadly, short sighted politicians failed to take the necessary steps. The engineers can do the work, but, they aren't being given sufficient resources... this is an almost criminal act... they really need a task force led by a single stron person with sufficient funding and authority... unfortunately, it may be too late.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by chancremechanic
No, they should learn from the Dutch. I'm simply amazed that the moronic mayor of N.O. hasn't consulted with Dutch engineers. Should Holland be abandoned simply because their dykes are holding back the North Sea successfully and have been for years?
Sorry CM, But I don't really think a City Mayor controls Federal spending and funding of a national/State project like a levee project that is maintained by the National Army Corps of Engineers. Nice try but you got the wrong guy. The Corp of Engineers is responsible for contacting any Dutch agencies if that is what needs to be done. That project is out of his control. The funding was signed by the Clinton administration. But the funding was reversed under the Bush administration.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HumeA
Should N.O. be abandonned? Or should man continue to attempt to defy nature?
I wish I knew less about this...
It is so ugly. Basically, they should abandon the Lower 9th Ward, New Orleans East, lots of St. Bernard Parish, and most of Lake View as Green Space. These are the "bowls" the FEMA and state engineers talk about. But they won't. There is and will be more good money after bad. You have never seen anything so depressing. All I could ask myself last October touring the region was, "Where do you start?"
Good people, screwed by history. And this was a town where subsistence living was a high art.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by cashthetrash
Sorry CM, But I don't really think a City Mayor controls Federal spending and funding of a national/State project like a levee project that is maintained by the National Army Corps of Engineers. Nice try but you got the wrong guy. The Corp of Engineers is responsible for contacting any Dutch agencies if that is what needs to be done. That project is out ...[text shortened]... gned by the Clinton administration. But the funding was reversed under the Bush administration.
Good point...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by avantguard
I wish I knew less about this...
It is so ugly. Basically, they should abandon the Lower 9th Ward, New Orleans East, lots of St. Bernard Parish, and most of Lake View as Green Space. These are the "bowls" the FEMA and state engineers talk about. But they won't. There is and will be more good money after bad. You have never seen anything so depressing. Al ...[text shortened]... od people, screwed by history. And this was a town where subsistence living was a high art.
Excellent post, avantguard.