Go back
Capitalism vs. Socialism

Capitalism vs. Socialism

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Which do you think is the superior economic system? When I say socialism I don't mean the pseudo-socialism of cold war era USSR.

Do you think that the world's economic system will evolve to socialism (as Marx said)?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Vote Up
Vote Down

how bout a two-tier system ... people who can, on capitalism, people who can't or are disinclined, on socialism (rather than welfare), and a set donation from the capitalist folks ... with a single shared vote come election time for the socialists ...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by zeeblebot
how bout a two-tier system ... people who can, on capitalism, people who can't or are disinclined, on socialism (rather than welfare), and a set donation from the capitalist folks ... with a single shared vote come election time for the socialists ...
Sounds like a recipe for the creation of aristocratic upper-class to me...

And a single vote for all of the lower tier? Seems like all votes would then go the way of the upper tier, ensuring that very few of the lower tier ever wormed their way to relative prosperity.

The main problem I see with socialism is that it enroaches on personal freedom.

The main problem with capitalism is that people use their personal freedom for wasteful ends (just look all the packaging thrown out in the west). And capitalism is hardly working, is it?

Vote Up
Vote Down

I think a forum of communism really where the state has more power over something’s but less over others.

I think that everyone has an equal right to education and healthcare and so private schools and hospitals should be integrated into public ones so everyone can use them free of charge.

The state should impose restrictions on businesses to reduce waste and offer more jobs ideally reducing unemployment also it should provide care for the homeless.

Lastly I think a world without money would be a better world but at the moment this is a far off ideal that would be very hard to plan and carry out.

Lastly Ithink a world without money would be a better world but at the moment this is a far off ideal.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Will Everitt
I think a forum of communism really where the state has more power over something’s but less over others.

I think that everyone has an equal right to education and healthcare and so private schools and hospitals should be integrated into public ones so everyone can use them free of charge.

The state should impose restrictions on businesses to redu ...[text shortened]... Ithink a world without money would be a better world but at the moment this is a far off ideal.
In practice, the main failing of any system is the people that are in it.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lukemcmullan
Which do you think is the superior economic system? When I say socialism I don't mean the pseudo-socialism of cold war era USSR.

Do you think that the world's economic system will evolve to socialism (as Marx said)?
I'll get back on this when I'm sober.



EDIT: If I remember

Vote Up
Vote Down

Best economic system?

Capitalism of course.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by zeeblebot
how bout a two-tier system ... people who can, on capitalism, people who can't or are disinclined, on socialism (rather than welfare), and a set donation from the capitalist folks ... with a single shared vote come election time for the socialists ...
We have something like that in Canada, and we're getting screwed. Our system needs to be overhauled, because I believe it can work.

Realistically the Capitalist system is better, but I'd prefer a good working socalist system. If anybody can figure out how to make it work, let me know.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lukemcmullan
Sounds like a recipe for the creation of aristocratic upper-class to me...

And a single vote for all of the lower tier? Seems like all votes would then go the way of the upper tier, ensuring that very few of the lower tier ever wormed their way to relative prosperity.

The main problem I see with socialism is that it enroaches on personal freedom. ...[text shortened]... (just look all the packaging thrown out in the west). And capitalism is hardly working, is it?
not upper class, middle class ... what's wrong with that? ...

why isn't capitalism working? ...

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by zeeblebot
not upper class, middle class ... what's wrong with that? ...

why isn't capitalism working? ...
If capitalism works, how come half the people in the world have to live on less than two dollars a day?

Oh sorry, why?

Mainly because it is human nature to desire power. Money buys power and so we have greed for money. This is the downfall of all economic systems.

Vote Up
Vote Down

read Walden Two .... been a while since i have, i forget how it turns out ... there are still communes in santa cruz, ca, i think and a few on the east coast ...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by zeeblebot
read Walden Two .... been a while since i have, i forget how it turns out ... there are still communes in santa cruz, ca, i think and a few on the east coast ...
http://thefec.org/

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lukemcmullan
If capitalism works, how come half the people in the world have to live on less than two dollars a day?

Oh sorry, why?

Mainly because it is human nature to desire power. Money buys power and so we have greed for money. This is the downfall of all economic systems.
Because they live in socialist countries.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Siskin
Because they live in socialist countries.
Yea, you're right, because the vast majority of African countries are socialist.