Go back
Does the UK need a replacement for Trident?

Does the UK need a replacement for Trident?

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by scottishinnz
Bees die when they sting you. Basically stinging causes their guts to be ripped out.
Not if they're fighting other animals of their own species, which is what the stinger evolved for.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by huckleberryhound
Are you suggesting i do not understand what a detterant is?
Bieng someone, as a lot of us were, i grew up in the nuclear age, so i know quite well what a detterant is.
Don't try to patronise me mate.
I am not suggesting that. Sorry if it came accross that way, I can sometimes sound patronizing without meaning to (I tend to say everything that is relevant about the subject, no matter how obvious). No, I am saying that the nuclear detterant overused, and that most of the countries with nuclear weapons should stop producing them, since their only purpose is to scare, and that it might be better not to use the detterrant.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Varg
No, you're wrong - having highly trained and disciplined archers is what made England great - we should keep that up!
No, you're wrong - massive population growth is what made the Angles great. England needs to keep breeding and breeding.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
Not if they're fighting other animals of their own species, which is what the stinger evolved for.
I don't know about that I'm afraid - I'm no entymologist. I'll have to look it up.

My understanding of why bees evolved their sting, and it's death sentence was rather more based on heredity than usage. I'm sure you know, but I'll spell it out for others. Female Bees within one hive are all genetic sisters, however they are rather more closely related to each other than sisters of many other species. In most species, two sisters are likely to share around 50% of each others genes. In social insects however, it is normally around the 75% mark (for reasons I won't go into here - but if you're interested read Dawkins "Selfish gene" for a concise, easy to read, explanation). It is because of this close relatedness that female bees (who are non-reproductive, except for the hive queen) are willing to sacrifice their own lives, since she can help more copies of her genes to survive by protecting the production of her sisters than she could by running away and breeding herself.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
No, you're wrong - massive population growth is what made the Angles great. England needs to keep breeding and breeding.
No, you're wrong - High population growth can be attributed to an abundance of food, due to England's moist, warm, stable, climate. England needs more rain.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by scottishinnz
No, you're wrong - High population growth can be attributed to an abundance of food, due to England's moist, warm, stable, climate. England needs more rain.
Well, I do have to admit - high population growth does correlate with the abundance of moist, warm...

Oh you mean the weather!

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by scottishinnz
I don't know about that I'm afraid - I'm no entymologist. I'll have to look it up.

My understanding of why bees evolved their sting, and it's death sentence was rather more based on heredity than usage. I'm sure you know, but I'll spell it out for others. Female Bees within one hive are all genetic sisters, however they are rather more closely rel ...[text shortened]... ng the production of her sisters than she could by running away and breeding herself.
is this about stinger missiles ?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Redmike
The nuclear submarine missile system, Trident, is reaching obsolesence.

We are told we need a replacement, and it looks like this will happen without much in the way of a debate.

This is despite:

- it will cost £25-£40 billion, which could pay for 120,000 new qualified nurses each year for the next 10 years or 60,000 new teachers every year for 20 y ...[text shortened]... protecting us' (from whom, exactly?), they just make us more vulnerable to terrorist attacks
They need one for the gum "Trident" because their teeth are just awful.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by scottishinnz
Bees die when they sting you. Basically stinging causes their guts to be ripped out. Wasps, on the other hand, do not die....
that was the ponit, I was reffering to retaliation capability in the event we were attacked with nuclear weapons. we die they die, so like a bee sting it works as a deterant to attack us but is fairly useless as an offensive weapon. I think the bee analogy works quite well.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by googlefudge
that was the ponit, I was reffering to retaliation capability in the event we were attacked with nuclear weapons. we die they die, so like a bee sting it works as a deterant to attack us but is fairly useless as an offensive weapon. I think the bee analogy works quite well.
Works great until someone doesn't really care if they die. We seem to have seen a resurgence in that kind of idea over the past few years.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Redmike
The nuclear submarine missile system, Trident, is reaching obsolesence.

We are told we need a replacement, and it looks like this will happen without much in the way of a debate.

This is despite:

- it will cost £25-£40 billion, which could pay for 120,000 new qualified nurses each year for the next 10 years or 60,000 new teachers every year for 20 y protecting us' (from whom, exactly?), they just make us more vulnerable to terrorist attacks
I totally agree we should n't replace it.

The government shouldn't spend the saving, they should tax us less.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by endersgame
i think u forget this 2006 its british forces not english. Anyway nukes are used as a deterrent so that other nations see that britian means business and that we are not a nation that hides behind the US.
The irony of the fact that the replacement nuclear weapons will be leased from the US and the US will have some say over their usage is perhaps lost on you.

Vote Up
Vote Down

The UK should have its own independant system.