Go back
Father's Day

Father's Day

Debates


The US first Father’s Day was celebrated on June 19, 1910, in the state of Washington.

Has being a father changed since 1910? The intrinsic role "father."

I am of course thinking of economics and progress and science and we know now compared to 1910 . It's a different world. Does that change the role father?

Maybe we can do this without mentioning personal politics and criticizing women. Maybe we can stick to our personal experiences - our house, our street, our neighborhood. Not what we see on TV or in our echo chambers.

We know what people trying to get likes and influence us think - what do you think? What have you seen?

There is a great passage in Stephen King's book On Writing where he talks about taking pen to paper and reporting back what you have seen. You have a singular experience in your home and your town - what have you seen in your family. Your dad and your dad's dad.

Has being a father changed since 1910? The intrinsic role "father."

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Bish

Pros and cons with the new father figure, I would think.


@Bish said
The US first Father’s Day was celebrated on June 19, 1910, in the state of Washington.

Has being a father changed since 1910? The intrinsic role "father."

I am of course thinking of economics and progress and science and we know now compared to 1910 . It's a different world. Does that change the role father?

Maybe we can do this without mentioning personal politics an ...[text shortened]... Your dad and your dad's dad.

Has being a father changed since 1910? The intrinsic role "father."
No. Conditions change, but the role of ‘father’ is bound up with the archetypes of being a mature ‘male.’ Jung labeled them King, Warrior, Magician, Lover, but you could parse them many different ways. Taking the journey that leaves the ‘boy’ behind while not falling into ‘shadow’ has always been the game. πŸ˜†

Ordering and protecting the family
Enduring hardship and taking action on their behalf
Working out thoughtful and clever solutions to help
Loving and caring for individuals and being passionate about the family succeeding

I think these apply in any age. πŸ˜†


@spruce112358 said
No. Conditions change, but the role of ‘father’ is bound up with the archetypes of being a mature ‘male.’ Jung labeled them King, Warrior, Magician, Lover, but you could parse them many different ways. Taking the journey that leaves the ‘boy’ behind while not falling into ‘shadow’ has always been the game. πŸ˜†

Ordering and protecting the family
Enduring hardship and t ...[text shortened]... or individuals and being passionate about the family succeeding

I think these apply in any age. πŸ˜†
I would add teaching your children the aspects of perparatioin for the many practical facets of life as well. Yeah, money, economics, what investments are about. Start with $100 (which they have to 'earn'πŸ˜‰ and set up what looks like a real investment account. Put 4 stocks in there that start off with their values 3 months ago, and show a graph of how they grow each week or so....show NVDA to go up, and then 'oh no.. 😲 " It goes down! but then it turns north again , to teach patience. You will know what it is going to do on that graph. They'll learn thte value of investing. $1000 in 1980 would be worth $40k today (6% annual return). Have loser stock in there as well so they will know there er no guarantees, teach them risk in life. And so it goes.

At the end of 3 month, give them back $115!!!!!!

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Torunn said
@Bish

Pros and cons with the new father figure, I would think.
Is it different in Gothenburg than Madison Wisconsin? Or is it universal?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@spruce112358 said
No. Conditions change, but the role of ‘father’ is bound up with the archetypes of being a mature ‘male.’ Jung labeled them King, Warrior, Magician, Lover, but you could parse them many different ways. Taking the journey that leaves the ‘boy’ behind while not falling into ‘shadow’ has always been the game. πŸ˜†

Ordering and protecting the family
Enduring hardship and t ...[text shortened]... or individuals and being passionate about the family succeeding

I think these apply in any age. πŸ˜†
I think this is exactly right. But it feels like something is different. Or missing.

The simple fact is we know more now. There is a lot of science about why marriages work or don't work. There are books on How to Win Friends & Influence People. Invest in college or trade school or third options - complicated decisions. Options that weren't there for most everyone in 1910.

Does the fact that there is just more knowable information now mean fathers have to invest more time into learning so they can teach?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AverageJoe1 said
I would add teaching your children the aspects of perparatioin for the many practical facets of life as well. Yeah, money, economics, what investments are about. Start with $100 (which they have to 'earn'πŸ˜‰ and set up what looks like a real investment account. Put 4 stocks in there that start off with their values 3 months ago, and show a graph of how they grow each wee ...[text shortened]... ntees, teach them risk in life. And so it goes.

At the end of 3 month, give them back $115!!!!!!
This is so smart. But how do you not influence them - not the right word - but how do you teach them to make their own investing decisions instead of just listening to yours?

Do we teach trust by having trust? If so, has that always been the case?

Or is taking the time to teach your kids the difference between an investment and an expenditure a luxury of the last 80 years? ( "Post-WWII" )


@Bish said
This is so smart. But how do you not influence them - not the right word - but how do you teach them to make their own investing decisions instead of just listening to yours?

Do we teach trust by having trust? If so, has that always been the case?

Or is taking the time to teach your kids the difference between an investment and an expenditure a luxury of the last 80 years? ( "Post-WWII" )
My post not written well, sorry, Anyway, depends on the age, I guess. A child would say 'APPL' cause she likes apples. But do the 3 months in any event, so you will know what the bogus chart is going to show as the 3 months goes by. You will actually decide what the child's results will be. There will obviously be a win when it is over, with a bit of nail biting. Stay the course!, you might say. Buy on this dip that just happened,,,,,,,NVDA a great company, it will go back up!! Tell her why it dipped.
I hope you get the idea...devise your own Scheme. After the 3 months, get them into a real market at Etrade.com. A Vanguard 500 index fund is safe enough, and she would not be trading, just watching. A 20-yr old? Get fancier, and more money. And maybe the real investment track. At least tell them. You don't want to see the train take off and they ask you why you didn't tell them it was leaving the station!

Great question about luxury spending instead of responsibility,,,,daddy's money, etc. Make them earn every dime, tell them you are leaving your money to the Boys&Girls Club. Serously, actually. If you don't, they will be sorryass.l

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AverageJoe1 said
My post not written well, sorry, Anyway, depends on the age, I guess. A child would say 'APPL' cause she likes apples. But do the 3 months in any event, so you will know what the bogus chart is going to show as the 3 months goes by. You will actually decide what the child's results will be. There will obviously be a win when it is over, with a bit of nail biting. S ...[text shortened]... aving your money to the Boys&Girls Club. Serously, actually. If you don't, they will be sorryass.l
No, the post was written fine. And I agree.

Teach them about compound interest as soon as they will understand it. It is different for everyone.

If you are not making money while you are sleeping, you will work the rest of your life. Warren Buffet maybe? Someone said that - not meπŸ’²


@Bish said
No, the post was written fine. And I agree.

Teach them about compound interest as soon as they will understand it. It is different for everyone.

If you are not making money while you are sleeping, you will work the rest of your life. Warren Buffet maybe? Someone said that - not meπŸ’²
Having written all that, I'd be remiss to not say that they should be introuced to the needs of those in need, charitable endeavors. Have them work once a week volunteering, they must witness those less fortunate, and taught how just their presence can greatly help people

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AverageJoe1 said
Having written all that, I'd be remiss to not say that they should be introuced to the needs of those in need, charitable endeavors. Have them work once a week volunteering, they must witness those less fortunate, and taught how just their presence can greatly help people
Agreed, the two are not mutually exclusive. There is so much to teach today.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AverageJoe1 said
I would add teaching your children the aspects of perparatioin for the many practical facets of life as well. Yeah, money, economics, what investments are about. Start with $100 (which they have to 'earn'πŸ˜‰ and set up what looks like a real investment account. Put 4 stocks in there that start off with their values 3 months ago, and show a graph of how they grow each wee ...[text shortened]... ntees, teach them risk in life. And so it goes.

At the end of 3 month, give them back $115!!!!!!
Sure. πŸ˜†

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Bish said
I think this is exactly right. But it feels like something is different. Or missing.

The simple fact is we know more now. There is a lot of science about why marriages work or don't work. There are books on How to Win Friends & Influence People. Invest in college or trade school or third options - complicated decisions. Options that weren't there for most everyone in 1910. ...[text shortened]... more knowable information now mean fathers have to invest more time into learning so they can teach?
We can never become experts in everything our kids will need to learn - there is too much info, as you say. Luckily, kids mostly learn by observing us ie ‘little sponges’ rather than from us teaching. In the old days that meant they would learn our trade, but today it’s more about learning behaviors. πŸ˜†

Vote Up
Vote Down

@AverageJoe1 said
My post not written well, sorry, Anyway, depends on the age, I guess. A child would say 'APPL' cause she likes apples. But do the 3 months in any event, so you will know what the bogus chart is going to show as the 3 months goes by. You will actually decide what the child's results will be. There will obviously be a win when it is over, with a bit of nail biting. S ...[text shortened]... aving your money to the Boys&Girls Club. Serously, actually. If you don't, they will be sorryass.l
I hope, for your daughters sake, that there is something in your life more important than money.

1 edit

@Suzianne said
I hope, for your daughters sake, that there is something in your life more important than money.
I speak of being a success in whatever your endeavor.

This one finds fault with my post above, to wit,,,,,


would add teaching your children the aspects of perparatioin for the many practical facets of life as well. Yeah, money, economics, what investments are about. Start with $100 (which they have to 'earn'πŸ˜‰ and set up what looks like a real investment account. Put 4 stocks in there that start off with their values 3 months ago, and show a graph of how they grow each week or so....show NVDA to go up, and then 'oh no.. 😲 " It goes down! but then it turns north again , to teach patience. You will know what it is going to do on that graph. They'll learn thte value of investing. $1000 in 1980 would be worth $40k today (6% annual return). Have loser stock in there as well so they will know there er no guarantees, teach them risk in life. And so it goes.

At the end of 3 month, give them back $115!!!!!!

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.