Go back
Gabby Petito

Gabby Petito

Debates

3 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

(Google it if you're not in the US and/or stuck under a rock and haven't seen the news in the past week.)

I'm kind of ambivalent.

On the one hand, with 20/20 hindsight, the police might have been able to spot that a serious situation was afoot and done more.

On the other hand, what realistically could they have done that would not violate anybody's rights? Laundrie hadn't committed any obvious crimes. It's not like they could have arrested him and held him for long. They could have tried to separate them or tried to get her hooked up with an organization that could have protected her; but they couldn't have forced her.

I see a lot of people screaming that the police should have spotted the signs of abuse. Fair enough. But what could they have done about it without hard evidence or a willing accuser?


@sh76 said
(Google it if you're not in the US and/or stuck under a rock and haven't seen the news in the past week.)

I'm kind of ambivalent.

On the one hand, with 20/20 hindsight, the police might have been able to spot that a serious situation was afoot and done more.

On the other hand, what realistically could they have done that would not violate anybody's rights? Laundrie hadn ...[text shortened]... use. Fair enough. But what could they have done about it without hard evidence or a willing accuser?
Such crimes are so sporadic and unpredictable yet people talk with 20-20 hindsight


@sh76 said
(Google it if you're not in the US and/or stuck under a rock and haven't seen the news in the past week.)

I'm kind of ambivalent.

On the one hand, with 20/20 hindsight, the police might have been able to spot that a serious situation was afoot and done more.

On the other hand, what realistically could they have done that would not violate anybody's rights? Laundrie hadn ...[text shortened]... use. Fair enough. But what could they have done about it without hard evidence or a willing accuser?
This appears to be a somewhat grey area where issues of what the police should have done bumps up against issues of probable cause involving search warrants, surveillance etc. I don't know enough about the law to have a strong stance on this one, but hopefully once this case is over something will happen that will give the police the tools to track suspects closer without those tools being misused.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@sh76 said
(Google it if you're not in the US and/or stuck under a rock and haven't seen the news in the past week.)

I'm kind of ambivalent.

On the one hand, with 20/20 hindsight, the police might have been able to spot that a serious situation was afoot and done more.

On the other hand, what realistically could they have done that would not violate anybody's rights? Laundrie hadn ...[text shortened]... use. Fair enough. But what could they have done about it without hard evidence or a willing accuser?
What if he is innocent?
He has not been charged with a crime.

Vote Up
Vote Down

I am very sorry to learn that the young woman is dead. I have not seen the autopsy report, so do not know whether, at this point, homicide is suspected. Certainly, her boyfriend's behaviour does not inspire confidence in an innocent explanation of her death; if he were innocent, he should have turned himself in by now. Still, innocent until proven guilty.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@earl-of-trumps said
Such crimes are so sporadic and unpredictable yet people talk with 20-20 hindsight
Bull hockey.

This literally happens every day in America.


@mchill said
This appears to be a somewhat grey area where issues of what the police should have done bumps up against issues of probable cause involving search warrants, surveillance etc. I don't know enough about the law to have a strong stance on this one, but hopefully once this case is over something will happen that will give the police the tools to track suspects closer without those tools being misused.
All we have at this point is hope.

With men in control, this may never change.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@moonbus said
I am very sorry to learn that the young woman is dead. I have not seen the autopsy report, so do not know whether, at this point, homicide is suspected. Certainly, her boyfriend's behaviour does not inspire confidence in an innocent explanation of her death; if he were innocent, he should have turned himself in by now. Still, innocent until proven guilty.
I believe he's guilty as sin, based on what we know about the case.

I also think his parents are aiding and abetting his flight from the law.

I'm beginning to think Gabby may never get justice.

The way police have responded to this mimics the way police responded to the murder of JonBenét Ramsey. She has never received justice either.


@moonbus said
I am very sorry to learn that the young woman is dead. I have not seen the autopsy report, so do not know whether, at this point, homicide is suspected. Certainly, her boyfriend's behaviour does not inspire confidence in an innocent explanation of her death; if he were innocent, he should have turned himself in by now. Still, innocent until proven guilty.
He has not been charged with a crime.
That means he does not have to turn himself in. In addition to that people could hide him and not be breaking the law at all. He is NOT a fugitive.....yet.


@suzianne said
I believe he's guilty as sin, based on what we know about the case.

I also think his parents are aiding and abetting his flight from the law.

I'm beginning to think Gabby may never get justice.

The way police have responded to this mimics the way police responded to the murder of JonBenét Ramsey. She has never received justice either.
"I also think his parents are aiding and abetting his flight from the law."

That is not illegal until he is charged with a crime.


@suzianne said
I believe he's guilty as sin, based on what we know about the case.

I also think his parents are aiding and abetting his flight from the law.

I'm beginning to think Gabby may never get justice.

The way police have responded to this mimics the way police responded to the murder of JonBenét Ramsey. She has never received justice either.
Just out of curiosity, whom do you believe should be brought to justice in the case of JonBenét Ramsey?

She didn't get justice because they never found the intruder. Unfortunate, but what are you going to do about it? What should the police have done differently?


@metal-brain said
What if he is innocent?
He has not been charged with a crime.
Yes, he has not been charged with a crime, though it seems pretty likely that he did it. He's entitled to a presumption of innocence in a court of law, not on an Internet forum.


@sh76 said
Yes, he has not been charged with a crime, though it seems pretty likely that he did it. He's entitled to a presumption of innocence in a court of law, not on an Internet forum.
He may have done it. It seems probable to me, but I don't have all the information law enforcement does. They may not want to charge him with a crime in hopes he will see it as a good sign and stop hiding. If that isn't the reason they probably don't have enough evidence to charge him with a crime.


He has been charged. He is now officially a fugitive.
Now he cannot claim he wasn't given time to come forward.


People are pointing out that Gabby is getting attention for her disappearance and murder because she is a pretty white girl. Most minorities do not get this much news media attention.

Is the corporate news media being run by racists?