Go back
Gift Tax

Gift Tax

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by finnegan
The purpose is not to avoid fraudulent transfer. It is to avoid legal transfers designed to legally avoid tax, primarily inheritance taxes. Gifts to children sound sweet but, for the very wealthy, and the only people likely to experience these types of taxation, this is about the intolerable scale of inherited wealth and privilege, which ensures that the ...[text shortened]... omy needs more wealthy kids enjoying a priviliged life on the back of their family trust?

. .
" for the very wealthy, and the only people likely to experience these types of taxation,"

...and people who realize that as long as the wealth has not been acquired by force, threats of force and fraud you have no claim on it and it's none of your business.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wajoma
" for the very wealthy, and the only people likely to experience these types of taxation,"

...and people who realize that as long as the wealth has not been acquired by force, threats of force and fraud you have no claim on it and it's none of your business.
Money is taxed whenever it changes hands in the stream of commerce. I don't see a moral difference between that and changing hands via a gift. Is it more moral to tax a transfer of wealth because it was done in exchange for a service than if it was done as a gift?

I'd love for someone to explain the logic behind that distinction.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by no1marauder
Amen.
I actually wasn't completely sold on that position until you convinced me a couple of years back. 😉


Originally posted by sh76
Money is taxed whenever it changes hands in the stream of commerce. I don't see a moral difference between that and changing hands via a gift. Is it more moral to tax a transfer of wealth because it was done in exchange for a service than if it was done as a gift?

I'd love for someone to explain the logic behind that distinction.
Well, the logic is that taxation is bad, so we shouldn't do it. But we still need someone to pay for our government, so we just have to wait for the fairy queen to provide tax dollars.