Israeli peace offer

Seitse

Doug Stanhope

Debates

28 Nov 06 10:41

Seitse

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined: 01 Jan 06
Moves: 33672

28 Nov 06 10:41

Two conditions:

(1) The Palestinians must release the Israeli soldier, Cpl Gilad Shalit,
who was captured by militants in June.

(2) And they must set up a national-unity government committed to
recognising Israel and renouncing violence.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6188986.stm

Sounds civilized and reasonable, let's see if those 2 qualities are
mirrored by the other side.

Redmike

Godless Commie

Glasgow

Joined: 06 Jan 04
Moves: 171019

28 Nov 06 10:44

Originally posted by Seitse
Two conditions:

(1) The Palestinians must release the Israeli soldier, Cpl Gilad Shalit,
who was captured by militants in June.

(2) And they must set up a national-unity government committed to
recognising Israel and renouncing violence.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6188986.stm

Sounds civilized and reasonable, let's see if those 2 qualities are
mirrored by the other side.

Do the Palestinians get to set pre-conditions too?

Or would that be 'uncivilised' of them?

Seitse

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined: 01 Jan 06
Moves: 33672

28 Nov 06 10:48

Originally posted by Redmike
Do the Palestinians get to set pre-conditions too?

Or would that be 'uncivilised' of them?

Let's wait and see, Mikey. We will have answers for these questions in a few days.

I do not like war (unlike you), so I really, really hope the middle east finds peace soon.

XanthosNZ

Cancerous Bus Crash

p^2.sin(phi)

Joined: 06 Sep 04
Moves: 25076

28 Nov 06 10:50

It won't work just like Oslo didn't.

Seitse

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined: 01 Jan 06
Moves: 33672

28 Nov 06 11:00

I simply love your insight and analysis depth.

AThousandYoung

Like a jungle

tinyurl.com/4emnyu9e

Joined: 23 Aug 04
Moves: 29247

28 Nov 06 11:03

Originally posted by Seitse
Let's wait and see, Mikey. We will have answers for these questions in a few days.

I do not like war (unlike you), so I really, really hope the middle east finds peace soon.

Why do you think he likes war?

spruce112358

It's All A Joke

Joined: 23 Oct 04
Moves: 4459

28 Nov 06 11:03

Originally posted by Seitse
Two conditions:

(1) The Palestinians must release the Israeli soldier, Cpl Gilad Shalit,
who was captured by militants in June.

(2) And they must set up a national-unity government committed to
recognising Israel and renouncing violence.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6188986.stm

Sounds civilized and reasonable, let's see if those 2 qualities are
mirrored by the other side.

This is absolutely reasonable, provided that:

1) Israel withdraws from the occupied territories and dismantles all illegal settlements.

2) Israel pledges never to invade Palestinian territory again.

Sound like a plan!

Let's get going!

XanthosNZ

Cancerous Bus Crash

p^2.sin(phi)

Joined: 06 Sep 04
Moves: 25076

28 Nov 06 11:05

Originally posted by Seitse
I simply love your insight and analysis depth.

Funny that you'd say that considering last time I tried mentioning the history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict you accused me of being a wikipedia baby and copy pasting.

Actually I didn't get any of my information from Wikipedia and I do know what I'm talking about.

And I do love how this thread has no actual debate posed in the first post.

Esoteric

Cognitive Junta

Joined: 02 Sep 05
Moves: 9122

28 Nov 06 11:08

Originally posted by Seitse
Two conditions:

(1) The Palestinians must release the Israeli soldier, Cpl Gilad Shalit,
who was captured by militants in June.

(2) And they must set up a national-unity government committed to
recognising Israel and renouncing violence.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6188986.stm

Sounds civilized and reasonable, let's see if those 2 qualities are
mirrored by the other side.

Let’s not forget the Palestinians offered a truce and was flatly refused by Israel a few days ago. But now all of a sudden it is Israel that has offered a truce and accepted by the Palestinians.

Seitse

Doug Stanhope

That's Why I Drink

Joined: 01 Jan 06
Moves: 33672

28 Nov 06 11:11

Originally posted by XanthosNZ
And I do love how this thread has no actual debate posed in the first post.

Then go somewhere else. Shooo!

der schwarze Ritter

Big D

Joined: 13 Dec 05
Moves: 26380

28 Nov 06 15:22

Originally posted by Redmike
Do the Palestinians get to set pre-conditions too?

Or would that be 'uncivilised' of them?

Preconditions of the so-called Palestinians:

1) All Jews in Israel must convert to Islam.
2) Those who do not must slit their throats or march into the sea.

Redmike

Godless Commie

Glasgow

Joined: 06 Jan 04
Moves: 171019

28 Nov 06 15:33

Originally posted by der schwarze Ritter
Preconditions of the so-called Palestinians:

1) All Jews in Israel must convert to Islam.
2) Those who do not must slit their throats or march into the sea.

Your ignorance is apparent again.

Go find out what proportion of Palestinians are actually Muslims, and you'll understand how stupid your post is.

ahosyney

Joined: 03 Sep 06
Moves: 9895

28 Nov 06 15:36

Originally posted by der schwarze Ritter
Preconditions of the so-called Palestinians:

1) All Jews in Israel must convert to Islam.
2) Those who do not must slit their throats or march into the sea.

Are all plastinians Muslims?

der schwarze Ritter

Big D

Joined: 13 Dec 05
Moves: 26380

28 Nov 06 15:48

Originally posted by ahosyney
Are all plastinians Muslims?

Last time I checked, the mission statement for Hamas still calls for the destruction of Israel.

Redmike

Godless Commie

Glasgow

Joined: 06 Jan 04
Moves: 171019

28 Nov 06 16:01

Originally posted by der schwarze Ritter
Last time I checked, the mission statement for Hamas still calls for the destruction of Israel.

Did it call for throat-slitting and sea-marching-into?