Go back
Over reach of government?

Over reach of government?

Debates

HG

Joined
22 Jun 08
Moves
8801
Clock
25 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

The City of Seattle just passed a new trash ordinance that would fine residents and businesses for throwing away too much food.
The new rules would allow garbage collectors to inspect trash cans and ticket offending parties if food and compostable material makes up 10 percent or more of the trash.
The fines will begin at $1 for residents and $50 for businesses and apartment buildings, according to the Seattle Times.
Seattle Public Utilities requested the new rules after falling short of its recycling goals of 60 percent of trash by 2015, according to the Times. The recycling rate in 2013 was 56 percent.
The Seattle city council vote on the new rules was 9-0.

n

The Catbird's Seat

Joined
21 Oct 06
Moves
2598
Clock
25 Sep 14
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Hugh Glass
The City of Seattle just passed a new trash ordinance that would fine residents and businesses for throwing away too much food.
The new rules would allow garbage collectors to inspect trash cans and ticket offending parties if food and compostable material makes up 10 percent or more of the trash.
The fines will begin at $1 for residents and $50 for bus ...[text shortened]... recycling rate in 2013 was 56 percent.
The Seattle city council vote on the new rules was 9-0.
It isn't really surprising. One of the things governments do well is find activities they know won't stop. What comes to pass is a defacto new tax which they get to spend.

RJHinds
The Near Genius

Fort Gordon

Joined
24 Jan 11
Moves
13644
Clock
25 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by normbenign
It isn't really surprising. One of the things governments do well is fine activities they know won't stop. What comes to pass is a defacto new tax which they get to spend.
Most of the people that run for those city council jobs seem to be people who enjoy spending other people's money.

JS357

Joined
29 Dec 08
Moves
6788
Clock
25 Sep 14
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Hugh Glass
The City of Seattle just passed a new trash ordinance that would fine residents and businesses for throwing away too much food.
The new rules would allow garbage collectors to inspect trash cans and ticket offending parties if food and compostable material makes up 10 percent or more of the trash.
The fines will begin at $1 for residents and $50 for bus ...[text shortened]... recycling rate in 2013 was 56 percent.
The Seattle city council vote on the new rules was 9-0.
Is there something wrong with democracy?

quote:

Seattle Form of Government

Seattle is a Charter City with a Mayor-Council form of government. The Mayor is directly elected by the voters and most executive departments report to the Mayor. There are nine City Councilmembers, two of whom are elected at-large, with the other seven elected by district. The only other elected position is the City Attorney, who is also elected at-large. The regular term of all offices is four years.

Candidates for these offices must be U.S. Citizens, registered voters in the City of Seattle at the time they file their declaration of candidacy, and able to read and write the English language.

All City office elections are non-partisan, which means the top two vote-getters in the primary election are placed on the general election ballot. This is true regardless of whether or not one candidate received a majority of the primary vote. If two people or less file declarations of candidacy for any of these offices, that office does not appear on the primary election ballot, but does appear on the general election ballot. Parties do not nominate candidates to appear on the ballot and the ballots do not identify the candidates by party. Parties can and do endorse and support certain candidates, but play no other role in nominating candidates or determining who is placed on the primary or general election ballot.

unquote

http://www2.ci.seattle.wa.us/ethics/votersguide.asp

edit: "The city outlawed recyclable items from the trash nine years ago, but SPU has collected less than $2,000 in fines since then, Croll says."

http://seattletimes.com/html/localnews/2024604656_citycompost1xml.html

HG

Joined
22 Jun 08
Moves
8801
Clock
25 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

so, how may garbage guys will climb down out of their truck, and inspect the load before dumping it?

rc

Joined
26 Aug 07
Moves
38239
Clock
25 Sep 14
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Hugh Glass
so, how may garbage guys will climb down out of their truck, and inspect the load before dumping it?
you don't need to inspect all loads , simply loads at random and that will provide an impetus for those that throw away too much food to curb it for they will never know when they may be called upon to be inspected. soon as the fines start being handed out they will start to comply.

JS357

Joined
29 Dec 08
Moves
6788
Clock
25 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Hugh Glass
so, how may garbage guys will climb down out of their truck, and inspect the load before dumping it?
Is the thrust of your OP the logistics of enforcement? Seattle has had a similar, successful ordinance concerning recyclables, for 9 years. This ordinance extends the concept to compostables.

n

The Catbird's Seat

Joined
21 Oct 06
Moves
2598
Clock
25 Sep 14

Originally posted by JS357
[b]Is there something wrong with democracy?
It is absolutely the worst form of government, once factions find they can gain control and get others to pay for their wants.

JS357

Joined
29 Dec 08
Moves
6788
Clock
26 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by normbenign
It is absolutely the worst form of government, once factions find they can gain control and get others to pay for their wants.
But all other forms of government have at their heart, a faction in control, no?

n

The Catbird's Seat

Joined
21 Oct 06
Moves
2598
Clock
26 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by JS357
But all other forms of government have at their heart, a faction in control, no?
Small republics have the best reputation for protection of minority rights. No government system offers perfect protection as they all involve humans in charge.

b
Enigma

Seattle

Joined
03 Sep 06
Moves
3298
Clock
26 Sep 14
2 edits

Originally posted by Hugh Glass
The City of Seattle just passed a new trash ordinance that would fine residents and businesses for throwing away too much food.
The new rules would allow garbage collectors to inspect trash cans and ticket offending parties if food and compostable material makes up 10 percent or more of the trash.
The fines will begin at $1 for residents and $50 for bus ...[text shortened]... recycling rate in 2013 was 56 percent.
The Seattle city council vote on the new rules was 9-0.
I live in Seattle, and can assure you most residents have little or no problem with this. These inspections would take less than 60 seconds each, and would be selected at random. Not exactly a massive government over reach. Sorry, but you'll have to look somewhere else for your next conspiracy.😲

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89763
Clock
26 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Let's do nothing to stop wasteful rubbish.

HG

Joined
22 Jun 08
Moves
8801
Clock
26 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by bill718
I live in Seattle, and can assure you most residents have little or no problem with this. These inspections would take less than 60 seconds each, and would be selected at random. Not exactly a massive government over reach. Sorry, but you'll have to look somewhere else for your next conspiracy.😲
how does a driver, even climb down out of his truck, and re-board in 60 seconds,, I cry BS....
I see these guys, they are rushed to complete routes...... and just how do you think they can inspect a loaded garbage can in 60 seconds..? And what happens when the citizen wants to debate the fine? Seattle is full of whining idiots, so I don't even believe the fact you stated as "they do not mind".. we have recycle bins for glass, cardboard, and lawn debris. There is no way anyone should agree to a wasted food fine...

HG

Joined
22 Jun 08
Moves
8801
Clock
26 Sep 14
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
Let's do nothing to stop wasteful rubbish.
No, we do recycle glass, cardboard and lawn debris,, but how in the heck do you monitor food waste..? who decides exactly what food waste is?
a loaf of moldy bread? uneaten pizza? ya right.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.