Go back
SNP Contradictions

SNP Contradictions

Debates

p

Isle of Skye

Joined
28 Feb 06
Moves
619
Clock
10 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

1) "Independance in Europe" - The idea that Scotland should be "independant" and leave the UK, but join the EU and most likely be amalgamated into their superstate within a few years.

Give more if you can think of them, and please comment.

W
Instant Buzz

C#minor

Joined
28 Feb 05
Moves
16344
Clock
10 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by princeoforange
1) "Independance in Europe" - The idea that Scotland should be "independant" and leave the UK, but join the EU and most likely be amalgamated into their superstate within a few years.

Give more if you can think of them, and please comment.
Do you believe that Norfolk should become independent again and then perhaps join the EU?

Vn

Joined
28 Aug 05
Moves
1355
Clock
10 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by princeoforange
1) "Independance in Europe" - The idea that Scotland should be "independant" and leave the UK, but join the EU and most likely be amalgamated into their superstate within a few years.

Give more if you can think of them, and please comment.
Post-colonialism


Ask any Tibetan if we live in a post-colonial age!!!

p

Isle of Skye

Joined
28 Feb 06
Moves
619
Clock
10 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wheely
Do you believe that Norfolk should become independent again and then perhaps join the EU?
Norfolk? I couldn't care less. What's that gotta do with it?

cs
i'll decide!

Glasgow Scotland

Joined
28 May 04
Moves
269599
Clock
10 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

rubbish, how is this a contradiction? are you seriously suggesting that the uk is not an independent country, of course it is.

it would sense for an independent scotland to join the eu, which under international law it would be anyway.

W
Instant Buzz

C#minor

Joined
28 Feb 05
Moves
16344
Clock
10 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by princeoforange
Norfolk? I couldn't care less. What's that gotta do with it?
Well, England used to be made up of many Kingdoms each, surprisingly, with their own king. These Kingdoms were united in the usual fashion, i.e. war. This, you'll be interested to note, is why the country is referred to as the United Kingdom.

Given your post about Scotland, I was wondering if you feel that Scotland should be independent and therefore, presumably, that the same right should apply to all the old Kingdoms, including Norfolk.

I may be doing you an injustice but I often find that people with right wing views, such as yourself, always look to the past but for them, the past seems to stop at Queen Victoria and they never think any earlier than that.

For example, do you feel the UK should adopt the Euro, if not, do you think we should re-adopt the groat?

R
Godless Commie

Glasgow

Joined
06 Jan 04
Moves
171019
Clock
11 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by chris stephens
rubbish, how is this a contradiction? are you seriously suggesting that the uk is not an independent country, of course it is.

it would sense for an independent scotland to join the eu, which under international law it would be anyway.
Would an indeppendent Scotland ever actually leave the EU in the first place?

cs
i'll decide!

Glasgow Scotland

Joined
28 May 04
Moves
269599
Clock
11 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Redmike
Would an indeppendent Scotland ever actually leave the EU in the first place?
no it wouldnt. this has continually been accepted by the european commission

N

Joined
04 Dec 05
Moves
2947
Clock
12 Jun 06
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by chris stephens
no it wouldnt. this has continually been accepted by the european commission
That's what proves that the european commission should be disbanded immediately.
A bunch of unelected bureaucrats living the life of O'Reilly at the expence of the taxpayers of Europe. But of course that doesn't include you.

Sorry, I meant to attach to this the post of our resident Scotch Socialist.

R
Godless Commie

Glasgow

Joined
06 Jan 04
Moves
171019
Clock
12 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nargaguna
That's what proves that the european commission should be disbanded immediately.
A bunch of unelected bureaucrats living the life of O'Reilly at the expence of the taxpayers of Europe. But of course that doesn't include you.

Sorry, I meant to attach to this the post of our resident Scotch Socialist.
Doesn't make any sense whichever post it is in reply to.

Yes, I will admit, I am not an EC commisioner, if that's what you're getting at.

🙄

W
Instant Buzz

C#minor

Joined
28 Feb 05
Moves
16344
Clock
12 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Redmike
Doesn't make any sense whichever post it is in reply to.

Yes, I will admit, I am not an EC commisioner, if that's what you're getting at.

🙄
Actually, I am a fairly strong supporter of the EU but would agree that I'd rather see the back of the Commission. What is the point of an elected parliament that can be over ruled by the unelected Commission.

R
Godless Commie

Glasgow

Joined
06 Jan 04
Moves
171019
Clock
12 Jun 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wheely
Actually, I am a fairly strong supporter of the EU but would agree that I'd rather see the back of the Commission. What is the point of an elected parliament that can be over ruled by the unelected Commission.
Absolutely - the commisioners make an absolute mockery of any idea of democracy in the EU.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.