Go back
The blast in Beirut

The blast in Beirut

Debates

1 edit

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-53656220

Did you see that?
That wasn’t an ammo dump going up. That second shock wave was a singular explosion (or lots of things going off in one go... which is very unlikely).

What do you reckon?
Bloody powerful whatever it was.

Poor people.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@shavixmir said
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-53656220

Did you see that?
That wasn’t an ammo dump going up. That second shock wave was a singular explosion (or lots of things going off in one go... which is very unlikely).

What do you reckon?
Bloody powerful whatever it was.

Poor people.
Tragic.
There was an initial blast (no video). A few smaller blasts throughout building, then the big one.
Looks like a nuclear blast.

1 edit

@mghrn55 said
Tragic.
There was an initial blast (no video). A few smaller blasts throughout building, then the big one.
Looks like a nuclear blast.
"Looks like a nuclear blast."

vapor clouds aren't unique to nuclear bombs. It would be a pitiful nuke. It was likely the result of a combustible cloud formation from the fire.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@shavixmir said
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-53656220

Did you see that?
That wasn’t an ammo dump going up. That second shock wave was a singular explosion (or lots of things going off in one go... which is very unlikely).

What do you reckon?
Bloody powerful whatever it was.

Poor people.
It's reported that it was an illegal fireworks storehouse.


@athousandyoung said
It's reported that it was an illegal fireworks storehouse.
According to the BBC [1] it was ammonium nitrate that had been impounded six years earlier from a ship that had run into technical difficulties en route to Mozambique. The owners abandoned the freighter and its cargo. The cargo had been stored in the warehouse. Because of the unclear ownership of the cargo and the judiciary not resolving the problem Lebanon's civil service couldn't, or didn't, deal with the problem.

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-53670839



@joe-shmo said
"Looks like a nuclear blast."

vapor clouds aren't unique to nuclear bombs. It would be a pitiful nuke. It was likely the result of a combustible cloud formation from the fire.
I was never suggesting it was a nuclear blast.
It just resembled one.
The mushroom cloud which is a characteristic of a nuclear explosion, is a function of the explosive yield.
Conventional weapons produce mushroom clouds when powerful enough.
US did so a lot in Afghanistan and Iraq.


@mghrn55

Absolutely. Remember MoaB? - Mother of all Bombs. Apt. That was one.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@Earl-of-Trumps

Just saw a bunch of videos of this blast. It looked like a 2 to 3 kiloton explosion, but not a nuclear one. If it was nuclear there would have been a 20 million degree ball of light which would make it much brighter than this one.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@bunnyknight said
If it was nuclear there would have been a 20 million degree ball of light which would make it much brighter than this one.
You must have some slick software to determine brightness from YouTube videos!

Vote Up
Vote Down

@bunnyknight said
@Earl-of-Trumps

Just saw a bunch of videos of this blast. It looked like a 2 to 3 kiloton explosion, but not a nuclear one. If it was nuclear there would have been a 20 million degree ball of light which would make it much brighter than this one.
Not a bad guesstimate.

Authorities said it was 2700 tons of ammonium nitrate that went up. Apparently it had sat there since 2013 without incident. A fire in the fireworks factory next door spread and ignited this.

Vote Up
Vote Down

300,000 homeless. Ho-lee scrip.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@suzianne said
Not a bad guesstimate.

Authorities said it was 2700 tons of ammonium nitrate that went up.
Without knowing the conversion rate for ammonium nitrate you can't say.

2700 tons of ammonium nitrate (apparently) works out as 2.2 kiloton explosive potential.

I'm sure Ponderable can verify or deny that.