Go back
The Three Ways to Spend Money

The Three Ways to Spend Money

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wajoma
A person can put their own value on that good, what it is worth to them, then we can work out what it has cost them then place those into one of the four catergories.
How will you place it into one of the categories ?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Barts
How will you place it into one of the categories ?
Give an example of a person spending money on a common good. Then we'll have something to work with.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wajoma
Give an example of a person spending money on a common good. Then we'll have something to work with.
I bought a fireman the other day.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wajoma
Give an example of a person spending money on a common good. Then we'll have something to work with.
A person pay taxes, government then uses that money to spends that money on common goods.

The point of common goods is that it is not rational for a private person to spend money on it.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KazetNagorra
I bought a fireman the other day.
There are probably better examples then you hiring a shirt lifter to act out fetishes.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Barts
A person pay taxes, government then uses that money to spends that money on common goods.

The point of common goods is that it is not rational for a private person to spend money on it.
Then your example falls very clearly into 3/ Spending other peoples money on other people.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Than your classification is meaningless in regards to efficiency as some categories will be more efficient depending on the type of product money is being spent on.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Barts
Than your classification is meaningless in regards to efficiency as some categories will be more efficient depending on the type of product money is being spent on.
We can go back and forth on that one, but you will now agree that there are only THE four ways to spend money?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Of course not, there are only "THE" four ways of spending money when we only classify by where the money comes from and where it goes, but you deliberately leave out significant other dimensions.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Barts
Of course not, there are only "THE" four ways of spending money when we only classify by where the money comes from and where it goes, but you deliberately leave out significant other dimensions.
We can go round and round in circles on which is most effcient, (some other time unfortunately) but in each case when money changes hands the exchange can be put into one of those four catergories.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wajoma
We can go round and round in circles on which is most effcient, (some other time unfortunately) but in each case when money changes hands the exchange can be put into one of those four catergories.
But how is the categorization meaningful?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Seeing as my contention was that your classification was not at all suited for the question (which one is most efficient) I have no problem conceding that it is indeed a way of classifying spending.

Question though, in the OP your question was.
"Which of these three generally results in the most efficient way to spend money and which is the worst"

Now you say that we're not going to talk about which one is most efficient. What is the use of the classification then ?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wajoma
We can go round and round in circles on which is most effcient, (some other time unfortunately) but in each case when money changes hands the exchange can be put into one of those four catergories.
And each time money exchanges hands the price goes up. 😉

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wajoma
1. Spend your money on yourself.
2. Spend your money on someone else.
3. Spend someone elses' money on someone else.

Which of these three generally results in the most efficient way to spend money and which is the worst, can they be applied to everyday examples.
1 is a common sense option, but needless to say the truth is that many people are incapable of using their money wisely.
2 is (ideally) the morally correct option, there's nothing more heart-warming than charity.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Wajoma
Haha, yep nice one, thought there was one more.
might also add
5. Spend money of another or of many others on different others. example: government ?compassion?.