Go back
UK Mag for black girls

UK Mag for black girls

Debates

Clock

https://www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-53561028/cocoa-girl-we-made-the-first-uk-black-girls-magazine

I think it's sad that in 2020 there is a need for a magazine
whose market is dictated by skin pigmentation.

Do you think this sort of publication helps or hinders black people ?

Clock
Vote Up
Vote Down

@wolfgang59 said
https://www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-53561028/cocoa-girl-we-made-the-first-uk-black-girls-magazine

I think it's sad that in 2020 there is a need for a magazine
whose market is dictated by skin pigmentation.

Do you think this sort of publication helps or hinders black people ?
It may help if you think of it this way:
Imagine separate products for people with small noses and big noses; or people with green eyes and blue eyes; or people with short legs and long legs; or people with black hair and red hair ...

Clock
Vote Up
Vote Down

@wolfgang59 said
https://www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-53561028/cocoa-girl-we-made-the-first-uk-black-girls-magazine

I think it's sad that in 2020 there is a need for a magazine
whose market is dictated by skin pigmentation.

Do you think this sort of publication helps or hinders black people ?
It’s called “cocoa girl”?
And it sells 11.000 copies per publication?

I can’t judge the need for it. What do normal girly mags for the age group 7-14 have in them? And does it miss things that black girls specifically need?

Say the normal mags don’t have role-models in them for black girls, then I can imagine it being a problem.

Much the same as you buy a boyly mag full of war stories and all the lead characters, the heroes, are white German girls fighting the Soviets in Southern Poland in March 1945. And that their main concern is make-up and cooking tips for on the run

Clock

@shavixmir said
It’s called “cocoa girl”?
And it sells 11.000 copies per publication?

I can’t judge the need for it. What do normal girly mags for the age group 7-14 have in them? And does it miss things that black girls specifically need?

Say the normal mags don’t have role-models in them for black girls, then I can imagine it being a problem.

Much the same as you buy a boyly ma ...[text shortened]... outhern Poland in March 1945. And that their main concern is make-up and cooking tips for on the run
You shouldn't run when cooking. Rookie mistake.

The more satisfying solution would be for regular magazines to become more inclusive in the stories they published.

Clock

@wolfgang59 said
https://www.bbc.com/news/av/uk-53561028/cocoa-girl-we-made-the-first-uk-black-girls-magazine

I think it's sad that in 2020 there is a need for a magazine
whose market is dictated by skin pigmentation.

Do you think this sort of publication helps or hinders black people ?
It helps if it's owned by Blacks

Clock
Vote Up
Vote Down

@athousandyoung said
It helps if it's owned by Blacks
Magazines for people owned by people would be my Utopian idea.

Clock

@wolfgang59 said
Magazines for people owned by people would be my Utopian idea.
Then this world must be your Utopia.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.