Go back
Was the USSR Communist

Was the USSR Communist

Debates


Originally posted by techsouth
If leaders were not corrupt, then communism would work fine.

But then again, if leaders were not corrupt, capitalism would work fine too. In fact, we could have kings and emperors and feudal lords, which would all work perfectly well if men were not corrupt.

All you're saying is that the USSR was not a true communist state because the leaders became ...[text shortened]... ally a "win-win" and I can't understand why it is so often viewed as an unfavorable arrangement.
Capitalism is all the power in the hands of the few.


Originally posted by shavixmir
Capitalism is all the power in the hands of the few.
No it's not.

(I can make an assertion too).


Originally posted by techsouth
No it's not.

(I can make an assertion too).
Thanks. Too many wild assertions go unchallenged.


Originally posted by techsouth
If leaders were not corrupt, then communism would work fine.

But then again, if leaders were not corrupt, capitalism would work fine too. In fact, we could have kings and emperors and feudal lords, which would all work perfectly well if men were not corrupt.

All you're saying is that the USSR was not a true communist state because the leaders became ...[text shortened]... ally a "win-win" and I can't understand why it is so often viewed as an unfavorable arrangement.
"All you're saying is that the USSR was not a true communist state because the leaders became corrupt."

That's not all the article said. It said that the right was happy to put the communist label on what was happening in the USSR, even though it was really state-run capitalism with corruption thrown in. This mislabeling suited the right, even though it distorted the aims and methods of the the cold war.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by techsouth
No it's not.

(I can make an assertion too).
1% of the world's population own more than 50% of its resources.

That's globalized capitalism for you.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shavixmir
Capitalism is all the power in the hands of the few.
And if you want that few to shrink to an oligarchy, then you want Communism/socialism.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by whodey
And if you want that few to shrink to an oligarchy, then you want Communism/socialism.
You still don't seem to have grasped the theory, dude.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.