commenting torney games

Just an idea on which I would like other opinions. Wouldn't it be interesting if games, once finished, would be analysed and
constructively commented and published by another player, preferably by a higher ranked player (or by peers at the top level)? It could
serve severeal purposes:
- instructive for the players
- motivation, a kind of recognition of the value of the play (therefor it should be critical, but constructive)
- could be used to determine "awards", and , who knows, a torney report could be composed

Of course that would require players that want to spend the effort going over others' games, and a kind of coordination of who would look
at which game(s). Any suggestions? I would be prepared to do my part...

Sin.

How bout every tourney game notated by both players and the winning
team captain(& his proxy if he so desires). Lets put them together in
pgn or Chessbase form for all to share.

Some of us are really unfamiliar with chess analysis, and especially
chessbase, etc. I think it would be a stretch to get something
meaningful out of every game!

I would consider it an option for the players - 2 years ago I never
looked at other folks game but in the past year I've got where I enjoy
trying to figure folks out thru there moves. Its said the more you
understand others the more you understand yourself... And that the
best way to understand a person, people or culture is thru the games
they play and how they play them.... Course I soound way too serious
here. I think annotation should be an option not a mandate but a
worthy option nonetheless

What we will do on this is that if there are some really good
games...people can submit them to the theory forum and I or some
others will annotate them.

Plus I think all games should be emailed to sintubin and myself and
then islanddoc has said he will database them...and maybe for a
small fee he can put them on a 3.5 disc and send them to people.

Dave
USA Captain

good idea. I just would like to know who would be willing to analyse
games. By no means I want to declare myself an authority, I have not
more experience other than a few contributions to a club-magazine.
Sin.

I will give it my best shot...plus have been looking at picking up a
copy of fritz or Hiarcs...and that will help.

And no people...don't want to hear it...i do all of my own playing.

Dave
USA Captain

Dave, I'll email you concerning this. I may have a plan that works well
for both of us...
Michael