1 edit
Originally posted by FMF
I did not claim to be quoting the Janis Joplin version. I take it you are fond of the song. What is your take on the sentiment about "freedom" that it expresses?
It's a song.
As an American, my feeling about 'freedom' is a bit more comprehensive. It doesn't fit on a 'bumper sticker'.
Originally posted by SuzianneNor does the line from the Kris Kristofferson song ~ which incidentally makes no claim to be comprehensive in its definition. It probably doesn't qualify as a definition of any kind. But the lyric has always struck me as a classic fragment of Americana which might resonate with someone who has heard the song ~ like you have ~ or who is an American ~ like you are.
As an American, my feeling about 'freedom' is a bit more comprehensive. It doesn't fit on a 'bumper sticker'.
Originally posted by FMFIts a great pity that an tempt at derailment took place on the basis of some pedantry. My father loved Kristofferson, when he came home from fitting out oil riggs in the North sea he would blast him out on a Sunday afternoon, him, John Denver and Rod Stewart.
Nor does the line from the Kris Kristofferson song ~ which incidentally makes no claim to be comprehensive in its definition. It probably doesn't qualify as a definition of any kind. But the lyric has always struck me as a classic fragment of Americana which might resonate with someone who has heard the song ~ like you have ~ or who is an American ~ like you are.
Freedom is relative at the best of times and perhaps when one has 'nothing left to lose', it affords the most possibilities although it cannot be true in all instances.
