Go back
give your verdict

give your verdict

General

Vote Up
Vote Down

Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he hasn't got any money. As a result the terrorist kills B.
Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nimbussz
Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he ...[text shortened]... Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?
Convicted of a lie, and sentenced to 10 years hard mime.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nimbussz
Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he ...[text shortened]... Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?
We never negotiate with terrorists. 😏

So he's home free.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nimbussz
Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he ...[text shortened]... Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?
1) aren't people like that called muggers instead of terrorists?
2) he should not be convicted of anything, never give in to extortion, it only leads to more extortion if you do.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nimbussz
Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he ...[text shortened]... Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?
maybe you should read up on the defintion of murder and man-slaughter.


In a word....no

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nimbussz
Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he ...[text shortened]... Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?
Murder. let him feel the full force of the law for entertaining morbid thoughts. set an example to all fellow citizens the consequences of being careful what you wish for.

Vote Up
Vote Down

perhaps Captain America should consult with one of the many
systems engineers or highschool drop-outs that hang around
in the debates forum claiming to be lawyers... no1marauder
for example

😉

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Seitse
perhaps Captain America should consult with one of the many
systems engineers or highschool drop-outs that hang around
in the debates forum claiming to be lawyers... no1marauder
for example

😉
Get lost, loser.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nimbussz
Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he ...[text shortened]... Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?
You have a friend you hate that much ?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nimbussz
Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he ...[text shortened]... Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?
I don't think he did anything that should be illegal.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by no1marauder
Get lost, loser.
LOL!

It's marvelous when I touch a nerve in a geek *giggles*

🙂

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sevenstar
You have a friend you hate that much ?
hey who needs enemies with friends like that 😀

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by nimbussz
Consider the following case. A and B are friends, but A secretly hates B and wishes B was dead. One day A and B walk down the road when suddenly a terrorist grabs hold of B and points a gun to his head. The terrorist threatens to kill B unless A gives him 1000 dollars. Now, A knows that he has 1000 dollars in his wallet, but he lies to the terrorist that he ...[text shortened]... Should A be convicted of murder, or of man slaughter, or something else, perhaps only of a lie?
Who cares?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by chrissyb
hey who needs enemies with friends like that 😀
so, how's your profile writing getting along, Chrissy?

😀

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sevenstar
so, how's your profile writing getting along, Chrissy?

😀
well i won't be using his services to write my profile again, but there is an agreement in place and i do want to get my $1.50 worth that i paid him. poor guy gets off distorting the truth for his own personal gratification. like i said, who needs enemies huh!