Go back
Godfather I or Godfather II

Godfather I or Godfather II

General

Clock
Vote Up
Vote Down

I know we have a couple of movies threads going so why stop? 🙂

I love both of these movies very much but if I had to pick one over the other I would have to go with GF II. I think Vito's story is so interesting and Fredo's betrayal was so powerful. I also think that's when both De Niro and Pacino were both at the top of their game.

Clock
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Joe Fist
I know we have a couple of movies threads going so why stop? 🙂

I love both of these movies very much but if I had to pick one over the other I would have to go with GF II. I think Vito's story is so interesting and Fredo's betrayal was so powerful. I also think that's when both De Niro and Pacino were both at the top of their game.
Sonny.

'Nuff said.

Clock
Vote Up
Vote Down

Forget the movies. Has anyone read the new The Godfather Returns book by Mark Winegardener? It is... BY FAR.... the WORST book I've ever read in my entire life. I've never even seen a movie I hated as much as this book. There are literally almost a dozen sex scenes, and (this isn't a big revelation or anything), Fredo turns out to be a homosexual. It is so, so, SO freakin' awful. I've literally thrown the book across the room probably five times now just out of frustration of what has happened to what started out as one of the greatest stories ever told. This guy has completely killed it. Completely. The Godfather 3 was The Godfather 2 compared to this freakin' thing.

Anyways though, I could never pick which movie I liked more. They both are brilliant. The best actors working together with one of the greatest directors ever on an adaptation from one of the greatest authors ever..... 😀

Clock
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by seraphimvulture
Forget the movies. Has anyone read the new The Godfather Returns book by Mark Winegardener? It is... BY FAR.... the WORST book I've ever read in my entire life. I've never even seen a movie I hated as much as this book. There are literally almost a dozen sex scenes, and (this isn't a big revelation or anything), Fredo turns out to be a homosexual. ...[text shortened]... ne of the greatest directors ever on an adaptation from one of the greatest authors ever..... 😀
Wow!! To say GF 3 is comparable to GF 2 when referencing this book must mean it is a friggin horrible book. I almost get physically ill trying to watch the third Godfather.

Clock
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Joe Fist
I know we have a couple of movies threads going so why stop? 🙂

I love both of these movies very much but if I had to pick one over the other I would have to go with GF II. I think Vito's story is so interesting and Fredo's betrayal was so powerful. I also think that's when both De Niro and Pacino were both at the top of their game.
I agree. GF 2, all the way.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.