Go back
Philip K. Dick

Philip K. Dick

General

Vote Up
Vote Down

Any PKD fans out there? I must have read about 20 of his novels over the years, as well as many short stories. Hadn't read any for quite a few years, and then recently i picked up a 2nd hand copy of 'Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?', on which the film 'Bladerunner' is loosely based. 'Total Recall' was also based on a PKD story, as was 'Minority Report'. My favourite PKD novels haven't, as far as i know, been made into films: VALIS, Ubik, A Maze of Death, The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch, and Galactic Pot-Healer. I think he is the greatest SF writer ever, and yet that he is much more than simply a 'genre' writer. Sure his actual prose was often a bit corny, especially in the novels he pushed out in two weeks, but it is always the ideas that shine through: ideas about madness, death, god, reality, subjectivity, decay, truth. I think 'Androids' is up there among the best of his novels. VALIS is my all-time favourite though.

Vote Up
Vote Down

add my name to the list... Great writer! Great Novels!

Vote Up
Vote Down

I enjoyed quite a few of them for their plots and great sci-fi ideas. But I find his writing (at a micro level, so to speak) poor - weak characterization, clunky dialogue, a schoolboy's outlook on sexuality, incompetent grammar even. Quite hard to read sometimes - I really struggled with 'The Man in the High Castle'.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Great Vision - Crap Writer

I have enjoyed his books immensely though, once you get past his (as Officer Dibble pointed out) poor writing style.

Most of his books tend to be short(ish) stories rather than epic novels, so his books are a good intro to sci-fi for those who are not regular readers.

Mark

Vote Up
Vote Down

I have to say I have never ventured down that path, though I have a copy of The Man in the High Castle. Maybe that's a very representative work ?

On a related note, I am about a dozen pages into Andrew Morgan's book Woken Furies, and I wonder if anyone has read anything by him and if they liked it? He won the Philip K. Dick award in 2004 (something i put a lot of respect in). But reading this new book is like reading some trashy, overly showey, populist take on cyberpunk - a bit of a let down! Anyone had the same experience?

h

Vote Up
Vote Down

Interesting.... I was just discussing Androids/Bladerunner with a friend this morning at work.