Go back
Should games like this be allowed?

Should games like this be allowed?

General

A

Joined
14 Jun 04
Moves
2260
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Go to open invites, if its till there, and look at a player named Durs game. It is mate in 1 and whoever accpets that game is screwed. Should this be allowed?

d

Canberra, Australia

Joined
07 Jan 03
Moves
19005
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Does it really matter? As far as I know set piece games don't affect ones win/loss record, so the player is just wasting his own time.

t
a unique loser

LIAAA

Joined
08 Oct 03
Moves
15848
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

everybody can see the position at which the game starts, so why not. If youi accept the game, you also accept the position. Second thing is that games that don't start from the normal position are all not rated. Only in tournaments these games are rated.

t
a unique loser

LIAAA

Joined
08 Oct 03
Moves
15848
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dyl
Does it really matter? As far as I know set piece games don't affect ones win/loss record, so the player is just wasting his own time.
Non rated games do affect your win/loss record, so I think set piece games are too, but I am not sure about this.

d

Canberra, Australia

Joined
07 Jan 03
Moves
19005
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by tejo
Non rated games [b]do affect your win/loss record, so I think set piece games are too, but I am not sure about this.[/b]
Really? Wouldn't this discourage people playing out lost positions with anyone for practice? Doesn't make much sense to me.

A

Joined
14 Jun 04
Moves
2260
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Point taken Tejo

D

Wellington, NZ

Joined
08 Jan 04
Moves
4274
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by tejo
Non rated games [b]do affect your win/loss record, so I think set piece games are too, but I am not sure about this.[/b]
Non-rated games affect your win/loss record, but set games don't (to my understanding).

rwingett
Ming the Merciless

Royal Oak, MI

Joined
09 Sep 01
Moves
27626
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Set piece games do not affect your won/loss record, nor do they affect your rating. I have played several of them.

turtlex
Picard Is My Captain

United States

Joined
21 Feb 03
Moves
244486
Clock
03 Aug 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down


Maybe "ian93" will take it?

NS
blunderer of pawns

Rhode (not an)Island

Joined
17 Apr 04
Moves
24785
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by DreamlaX
Non-rated games affect your win/loss record, but set games don't (to my understanding).
Set piece games do affect your win-loss record. I have played several with ElvenDreamGirl to help her with different endgame themes, and I vividly remember them changing my win-loss record. Not that I mind; my primary reason for being here is to continually improve my chess, not my win-loss totals.

M

Joined
12 Mar 03
Moves
44411
Clock
03 Aug 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Natural Science
Set piece games do affect your win-loss record. I have played several with ElvenDreamGirl to help her with different endgame themes, and I vividly remember them changing my win-loss record. Not that I mind; my primary reason for being here is to continually improve my chess, not my win-loss totals.
Are you sure? Because that is not what I understood, nor experienced. I have 3 to 5 setup games running on average, most of which I lose (because they are training/coaching games) and have never seen effect on my stats.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.