Go back
The right thing to do

The right thing to do

General

l
Ray

Red Hot Rebels Clan

Joined
27 Nov 02
Moves
19743
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Game 190987. I was 2 moves away from mate. I was at work playing when my boss walked in my office unannounced, how dare him. I was in the process of making my move. I moved the wrong rook, wanted to move the D rook. Now I don't think I can recover. My question is this. Would you take the win or realize it was a terrible mistake and resign, and ask for a rematch which I would gladly accept. What is the right thing to do?

V
Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined
20 Jan 03
Moves
14580
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Personally I would see the game was up and resign. If your opponent doesn't see it, maybe you could play from set position to show him how it would have gone?

V
Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined
20 Jan 03
Moves
14580
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Then again I once had somebody claim somebody had made their move for them and it wasn't their fault. But I was so close to winning, I had to carry on.
But I'm not sure what I could have done anyway, there is no way to delete a game after the first 2 moves as far as I know, somebody has to win it.

m

Joined
16 Feb 02
Moves
9503
Clock
22 Apr 03
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lionel
Game 190987. I was 2 moves away from mate. I was at work playing when my boss walked in my office unannounced, how dare him. I was in the process of making my move. I moved the wrong rook, wanted to move the D rook. Now I don't think I can ...[text shortened]... ematch which I would gladly accept. What is the right thing to do?
I don't have this problem.
When at work:I work.
When I come home:I play.
I never mix.It is a cocktail as described:you can make weak moves.
I think you got off lightly,you should have lost your job.
Linda.

l
Ray

Red Hot Rebels Clan

Joined
27 Nov 02
Moves
19743
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by misslead
I don't have this problem.
When at work:I work.
When I come home:I play.
I never mix.It is a cocktail as described:you can make weak moves.
I think you got off lightly,you should have lost your job.
Linda.
No more comments from the peanut gallery.

kirksey957
Outkast

With White Women

Joined
31 Jul 01
Moves
91452
Clock
22 Apr 03
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lionel
No more comments from the peanut gallery.
I play at work and I also work hard. Chess players make excellent employees. In fact if I were your boss, I would have walked over to you and said, "hey, let me look at that. You've got great position. In fact, so good that I'm going to give you a promotion. Why didn't you tell me you played chess? That's what this outfit needs- more brains! 😉 Kirk

m

Joined
16 Feb 02
Moves
9503
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lionel
No more comments from the peanut gallery.
Sorry.
Let him take the move back.
It's only fair.
Isn't it?
Peanut Linda.

l
Ray

Red Hot Rebels Clan

Joined
27 Nov 02
Moves
19743
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by misslead
Sorry.
Let him take the move back.
It's only fair.
Isn't it?
Peanut Linda.
How can you do that?

l
Ray

Red Hot Rebels Clan

Joined
27 Nov 02
Moves
19743
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by kirksey957
I play at work and I also work hard. Chess players make excellent employees. In fact if I were your boss, I would have walked over to you and said, "hey, let me look at that. You've got great position. In fact, so good that I'm going to give you a promotion. Why didn't you tell me you played chess? That's what this outfit needs- more brains! 😉 Kirk
This is serious, I'm about to lost 50 points.

m

Joined
16 Feb 02
Moves
9503
Clock
22 Apr 03
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lionel
This is serious, I'm about to lost 50 points.
This has to be a spoof.
I thought you were winding me up.
I only went along with it because I thought it was tongue-in-cheek.
You won.
Linda.

U

Steelers Country

Joined
12 Apr 02
Moves
32833
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lionel
Game 190987. I was 2 moves away from mate. I was at work playing when my boss walked in my office unannounced, how dare him. I was in the process of making my move. I moved the wrong rook, wanted to move the D rook. Now I don't think I can recover. My question is this. Would you take the win or realize it was a terrible mistake and resign, and ask for a rematch which I would gladly accept. What is the right thing to do?
I'd say to play on and hope he doesnt notice and if he does to keep playing and hope you can out play him.

latex bishop

Joined
20 Feb 02
Moves
58336
Clock
22 Apr 03
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lionel
Game 190987. I was 2 moves away from mate. I was at work playing when my boss walked in my office unannounced, how dare him. I was in the process of making my move. I moved the wrong rook, wanted to move the D rook. Now I don't think I can ...[text shortened]... ematch which I would gladly accept. What is the right thing to do?
Ray,

You have the ability to win from there - confidence :o)

I have made some terrible moves against some players on this site and got away with it, I have had people even fail to miss my Queen sitting there waiting to die as I was sitting cringing at the move I had just made.

It just makes the game a little more fun. One thing is for sure, if you resign you will loose the game for sure, if you play on you have a chance

Andrew

m

Joined
16 Feb 02
Moves
9503
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by latex bishop
Ray,

You have the ability to win from there - confidence :o)

I have made some terrible moves against some players on this site and got away with it, I have had people even fail to miss my Queen sitting there waiting to die as I was sitting cringing at the move I had just made.

It just makes the game a little more fun. One thing is for sure, if you resign you will loose the game for sure, if you play on you have a chance

Andrew
Talking about games in progress is against any form of rules.
We must not give advice or encouraugement about a game in progress.
Lionel you brought this "dilema"to this forum that you should lose 50 points.
Now because you went public,you are compromised.
Linda.

Q
Tovenaar

Dieren

Joined
20 Apr 02
Moves
355136
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lionel
Game 190987. I was 2 moves away from mate. I was at work playing when my boss walked in my office unannounced, how dare him. I was in the process of making my move. I moved the wrong rook, wanted to move the D rook. Now I don't think I can recover. My question is this. Would you take the win or realize it was a terrible mistake and resign, and ask for a rematch which I would gladly accept. What is the right thing to do?
I think you should only discuss this when the game is over and it is not.

Otto

TS

Joined
09 Apr 03
Moves
1205
Clock
22 Apr 03
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Quirine
I think you should only discuss this when the game is over and it is not.

Otto
I agree! This discussion is unethical and against the rules. Or are there any rules here that are followed?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.